Showing posts with label noise-mining. Show all posts
Showing posts with label noise-mining. Show all posts

Sunday, December 14, 2025

Pareidolia Progress: Neuroscientists Get Better and Better at Seeing Things in the Brain That Are Not There

 Our neuroscientists are getting nowhere in trying to show that there is a neural basis for human memory or human thinking. But they have something they can rely on to help hide their lack of progress:  pareidolia. Pareidolia is when you see patterns that aren't really there, like some guy examining his toast every day for years, and then one day saying, "I finally see the face of Jesus in my toast."  A scientist conjuring up some pareidolia can make a nice-sounding progress report when no real progress has been made. I describe some examples of this in my post "Scientists Have a Hundred Ways to Conjure Up Phantasms That Don't Exist." 

pareidolia

There are several factors driving an increase in the ability of neuroscientists to make these pareidolia reports of seeing things in a brain that are not there. They include the following:

(1) Technological improvements have made it more and more easy for neuroscientists to use microelectrodes to record activity from individual neurons. This type of invasive brain intervention yields much more data than you get from the non-invasive technique of reading brain waves by having someone wear an EEG cap with electrodes. Neurons fire randomly at a rate between about 1 time per second and about 300 times per second. Being able to get data from all the individual firings of a large set of neurons randomly firing is almost the perfect seed bed for pareidolia.  The more random, rapidly changing data you get, the easier it is to do noise-mining pareidolia in which you seek for patterns you are eagerly hoping to find. 

(2) Advances in computer programming and AI make it easier-than-ever to create computer programs that manipulate gathered brain data in arbitrary ways. Easy-to-use languages such as Python make it easier for neuroscientists who are not professional programmers to write such programs. AI tools such as ChatGPT allow the creation of artificially generated code that can be used as part of such programs. The easier it is to produce such computer programs, the easier it is to do the kind of "keep torturing the data until it confesses" work that is often the basis of pareidolia, or a pillar of pareidolia. 

(3) Advances in so-called artificial intelligence (AI) and the public accessibility of such techniques make it easier than ever to do noise mining or data mining to extract or construct patterns or claimed patterns that a human might night never be able to find or that humans would never say existed if the humans made a simple, straightforward examination of the data. 

We have a recent example of neuroscientists seeing things that are not really there is the paper "Dynamic coding and sequential integration of multiple reward attributes by primate amygdala neurons" which you can read here. We have two neuroscientists claiming to have found that "neurons frequently signalled reward probability in an abstract, stimulus-independent code." They provide no robust evidence for this claim. To qualify as decent evidence, a study like theirs would have required a study group size of at least 15 subjects. The study group size they used was the way-too-small size of only two subjects, both monkeys. 

Below from Figure 4 of the paper is some of the data gathered from monitoring several hundred neurons of the two monkeys, as they were either resting or presented with some kind of cue. 

The little blips are neuron firing or neuron firing spikes going on while these cues were presented. A human looking at this data will see no pattern. But the authors played around with what we might charitably call "analysis techniques," trying to find some way to squeeze some evidence of a pattern or a code out of this neural noise. In the paper these are called "general linear models" and are given names of GLM 1, GLM 2, GLM 3, GLM 4 and GLM 5. Describing each of these "models," the authors groundlessly claimed that each of them identified a particular neuron encoding in some different way. The claims are never justified, and seem like pure imagination. 

Procedures like this almost invariably involve computer programming code that passes the data through programming loops. It's kind of like what's depicted in the visuals below. 


keep torturing the data until it confesses

Normally you get an idea of how objectionable the data processing was by looking at the programming code used by the scientists. There is no excuse for any study of this failing to publish its code, as there are nowadays various platforms and web sites that make it very easy for someone to make their code publicly available online.  Typically in affairs such as this you can examine the programming code, and find some convoluted poorly documented mess that will demonstrate that the data was being monkeyed with in wild and weird ways. If, on the other hand, you were to find some clean, straightforward, well-documented code, it might be a sign of a respectable methodology. 

But often the scientists will not make their programming code publicly available. This is a strong reason for suspecting that the programming code involved is something that the scientists were embarrassed by, some programming horror they were too embarrassed to publish.  In the case of the paper discussed here ("Dynamic coding and sequential integration of multiple reward attributes by primate amygdala neurons" which you can read here), the authors have failed to make their programming code public.  We should have no confidence in any of the author's claims to have found "probability-coding neurons." but we can assume that the authors were not proud of their own coding. 

The authors are just engaging in the most groundless "Jesus in my toast" pareidolia when they make these claims:

"Amygdala neurons frequently signalled reward probability in an abstract, stimulus-independent code that generalized across cue formats. While some probability-coding neurons were insensitive to magnitude, signalling ‘pure’ probability rather than value, many neurons showed biphasic responses that signalled probability and magnitude in a dynamic (temporally-patterned) and flexible (reversible) value code. Specific neurons integrated these reward attributes into risk signals that quantified the uncertainty of expected rewards, distinct from value."

Making these claims the authors are like someone staring at 1000 photos of clouds in the sky, and finally declaring that he sees angel castles and animal ghosts. Among their procedural sins:

(1) They have not done a study with even one seventh of the study group size needed for a study like this to be taken seriously. 

(2) They have not revealed the exact details of their procedural method, because they failed to publish the programming code that their claims are dependent on. 

(3) Instead of testing a single hypothesis and declaring that it either succeeded or failed, they kept playing around with different ways of analyzing data until they found something they thought produced a publishable result. 

All claims that the authors make about finding neurons "encoding" something are spurious and groundless. Their description of the analysis algorithms they fooled around with is a description of a  tangled, tortured gobbledygook rigamarole, some "witches brew" of statistical spaghetti code shenanigans that the authors give no justification for. You could give the data they recorded to 100 neuroscientists and ask them whether they saw anything in the data; and not one of them would claim that they saw any evidence of "probability encoding neurons" unless you primed the pump by mentioning such a notion to them. 

Friday, October 10, 2025

How We Got Misinformed About "Grandmother Cells"

Each neuron fires between about 1 and 200 times per second, with the firing rate being unpredictable. So neurons are a noisy, unpredictable signal source; and that kind of source provides opportunities for noise mining and pareidolia, the occasional finding of some desired pattern by people scanning noisy, variable data looking for such a pattern. Similarly, at a restaurant that makes 200 pieces of toast every day using different types of bread, there is an opportunity for noise mining, in which someone checking each piece of toast may eventually claim to see the face of Jesus in a slice of toast. 

Let us look at the history of claims of "grandmother cells." The term refer to some neuron that might allegedly respond only when a person sees some particular type of visual, such as a picture of the person's grandmother. The 2002 article "Genealogy of the 'Grandmother Cell'" by the late Charles G. Gross gives us some background on how the idea of such a cell got started. Gross tells us this:

"The term originated in a parable Jerry Lettvin told in 1967. A similar concept had been systematically developed a few years earlier by Jerzy Konorski who called such cells 'gnostic' units."

So according to Gross, the concept of a "grandmother cell" arose independently of observations, without any empirical warrant.  But then Gross starts telling an unwarranted self-serving tale that evidence was found supportive of such an idea. He claims, "In the early 1970s, my colleagues and I working at M.I.T. in Cambridge, Massachusetts, reported visual neurons in the inferior temporal cortex of the monkey that fired selectively to hands and faces (Gross and others 1969, 1972; Gross 1998a)." Gross is here engaging in self-citation. Let us look at the papers Gross refers to, and see whether they actually gave any evidence to back up such a claim. 

  • The 1969 paper "Visual Receptive Fields of Neurons in Inferotemporal Cortex of the Monkey" by Gross and others which you can read here. We have no specific data backing up any claim that anything had been found like a neuron that only responds to some particular image. We merely have this vague statement: "There were several units that responded most strongly to more complicated figures. For example, one unit that responded to dark rectangles responded much more strongly to a cutout of a monkey hand, and the more the stimulus looked like a hand, the more strongly the unit responded to it." The paper gives no data backing up such a claim. 
  • The 1972 paper by Gross is the paper "Visual properties of neurons in inferotemporal cortex of the macaque." Only the first page of the paper is publicly available here. That page makes no claim backing up claims of anything like a grandmother cell. 
  • The "Gross 1998a" citation is a citation of the book "Brain, Vision, Memory" by Gross, which you can read here.  On page 198 Gross claims that "he did not publish a full account of a face-selective neuron until 1982," which shows that the previous two citations were inappropriate. On the same page Gross misspoke by claiming that "soon thereafter, a flood of papers on such cells appeared." No such flood occurred. He mentions a 1982 paper by Perrett, Rolls and Cann ("Visual Neurones Responsive to Faces in the Monkey Temporal Cortex"), which you can read here. 

Nothing that is in any of these citations supports the claim that anything like a face-selective cell or a hand-selective cell was discovered. If we look at the 1982 paper by Perrett, Rolls and Cann ("Visual Neurones Responsive to Faces in the Monkey Temporal Cortex"), which you can read here, we also find nothing impressive. The paper claims that "Of the 497 cells recorded in the STS region there was a sub-population of at least 48 cells which gave responses to the sight of faces that were two to ten times as large as the responses to other stimuli tested." There is no claim that these cells fired only when other faces were shown, and Figure 3 (cherry-picked as the strongest evidence of a "face responsive cell") shows the cell firing many times when things other than faces were shown. The graphs in the diagram are examples of cherry-picking, showing results from a few cells that seemed to fire the most when the subject was shown faces. 

Some mathematical analysis will show how unimpressive the result discussed above. In the study there were five types of sensory stimuli: faces, gratings/geometric stimuli, complex 3D stimuli, somatosensory stimuli, and auditory stimuli. Let us imagine that we are recording how 497 cells respond when a subject is exposed to one of a small number of categories of stimulus, such as five.  Given a high random variability in how the cells respond, with the firing rates varying randomly between 1 and 200 times per second, and given a relatively small number of trials, and only a small number of types of stimulus (such as only five), we would expect that by chance there would be about 10% of these cells that would fire twice as often or more when a subject is exposed to one of the five types of stimulus. So the reported result that "there was a sub-population of at least 48 cells which gave responses to the sight of faces that were two to ten times as large as the responses to other stimuli tested" is not something unexpected, assuming purely chance results, and no actual "face sensitivity" or "face selectivity" going on in the cells. 

The claim by Gross to have discovered neurons that "fired selectively to faces and hands" was false. Neither he nor anyone else discovered any such thing. All that was going on was noise-mining.  Monkeys were being shown different visual stimuli, including faces and things that were not faces. The firing of hundreds of neurons were recorded, and researchers were drawing attention to the cells that happened to have the highest firing rate when faces were shown. No evidence was being presented of more neuron firing during face observation than we would expect to see from a random set of randomly firing cells that fired with a high variability. 

Later in the 2002 article "Genealogy of the 'Grandmother Cell'" by Charles G. Gross, Gross makes this claim: "Starting 10 years later, these finding were replicated and extended in a number of laboratories (e.g., Perrett and others 1982; Rolls 1984; Yamane and others 1988) and were often viewed as evidence for grandmother cells." The references do not actually refer to any papers providing evidence for grandmother cells. The 1982 Perrett paper is discussed above, and did not find any such evidence, but merely claimed "Of the 497 cells recorded in the STS region there was a sub-population of at least 48 cells which gave responses to the sight of faces that were two to ten times as large as the responses to other stimuli tested."  The Rolls 1984 paper is the paper "Neurons in the cortex of the temporal lobe and in the amygdala of the monkey with responses selective for faces."  It is merely another paper picking out some cells out of hundreds that fired more often when faces were shown, while also firing when things other than faces were shown. 

None of the papers that Gross has cited could intelligently be interpreted as evidence for grandmother cells, so Gross misleads us badly by claiming that such papers "were often viewed as evidence for grandmother cells." Later Gross confesses, "However, most of the reported face-selective cells do not really fit a very strict criteria of grandmother/ gnostic cells in representing a specific percept, that is, a cell narrowly selective for one face and only one face across transformations of size, orientation, and color (Desimone 1991; Gross 1992)." At the end of the paper, Gross deceives us by trying to make it sound like these alleged "face selective" cells may be something like "grandmother cells." But no evidence he has presented or cited has given any evidence for such "grandmother cells." 

The next big development on this topic occurred when scientists started reading the firings of neurons in individual humans. This is something that cannot be done by simply having a person wear an EEG cap on his head. The reading of firings of individual neurons in humans requires the implanting of electrodes into the brain.  Some people with drug-resistant epilepsy have electrodes implanted in their brains so that doctors can figure out where is the best place to do surgery to help cure their epilepsy. Neuroscientists have tried to leverage the implanting of such electrodes, to study the firing of individual neurons in the human brain. 

This has often been a morally objectionable type of activity by neuroscientists. The type of electrodes implanted in a brain to evaluate a patient for epilepsy are called macroelectrodes.  The type of electrodes implanted to record the firing of individual neurons are called microelectrodes. There is never any medical justification for implanting microelectrodes in addition to macroelectrodes. A scientific paper tells us, "Sixty-five years after single units were first recorded in the human brain, there remain no established clinical indications for microelectrode recordings in the presurgical evaluation of patients with epilepsy (Cash and Hochberg, 2015)." In other words, there is no medical justification for implanting microelectrodes in the brains of epilepsy patients. Here is a quote from a scientific paper:

"The effects of penetrating microelectrode implantation on brain tissues according to the literature data...  are as follows:

  1. Disruption of the blood–brain barrier (BBB);
  2. Tissue deformation;
  3. Scarring of the brain tissue around the implant, i.e., gliosis 
  4. Chronic inflammation after microelectrode implantation;
  5. Neuronal cells loss."
What is going on with attempts to find something like grandmother cells in humans is typically a morally objectionable affair in which very sick people are being put to unnecessary risks for the sake of scientists seeking fame and glory. Such affairs are so morally dubious that we should have a natural tendency to distrust the statements of scientists doing such research, just as we should have a natural tendency to distrust the statements of any person engaged in a reckless or shady activity. 

Similar to claims of a "grandmother cell" are claims of a "Jennifer Aniston neuron" that was activated only when a epileptic subject was shown a picture of Jennifer Aniston. The claim is unfounded, and does not match the data in the original paper. For a discussion of the shady business that went when claims like this were made, see the last seven  paragraphs of my post here. 

plan for becoming famous scientist

At the link here, a vision scientist describes some of what is going in studies like the studies mentioned above:

"Neuroscience, as it is practiced today, is a pseudoscience, largely because it relies on post hoc correlation-fishing....As previously detailed, practitioners simply record some neural activity within a particular time frame; describe some events going on in the lab during the same time frame; then fish around for correlations between the events and the 'data' collected. Correlations, of course, will always be found. Even if, instead of neural recordings and 'stimuli' or 'tasks' we simply used two sets of random numbers, we would find correlations, simply due to chance. What’s more, the bigger the dataset, the more chance correlations we’ll turn out (Calude & Longo (2016)). So this type of exercise will always yield 'results;' and since all we’re called on to do is count and correlate, there’s no way we can fail. Maybe some of our correlations are 'true,' i.e. represent reliable associations; but we have no way of knowing; and in the case of complex systems, it’s extremely unlikely. It’s akin to flipping a coin a number of times, recording the results, and making fancy algorithms linking e.g. the third throw with the sixth, and hundredth, or describing some involved pattern between odd and even throws, etc. The possible constructs, or 'models' we could concoct are endless. But if you repeat the flips, your results will certainly be different, and your algorithms invalid...As Konrad Kording has admitted, practitioners get around the non-replication problem simply by avoiding doing replications.” 

Later in the same scientist's blog, we read this year 2023 comment: "Articles published during the past decade bemoaning the inability of mainstream neuroscience to generate replicable or even reproducible outcomes are too many to count."  In the same post the scientist states this:

"If we weren't living it, it would be hard to imagine how a research culture could have strayed so far from the path of rationality as has the culture of neuroscience. Fundamental problems in theory and method have long been flagged (e.g. Teller, 1984; Jonas & Kording, 2018; Brette, 2019), but critiques have left barely a trace on the hard-beaten track of routine, mainstream practice."

Monday, May 12, 2025

When Neuroscience Studies Find Nothing, Press Releases Still Claim Epic Breakthroughs

There is an English expression, "Heads I win, tails you lose." It describes a situation where a game is rigged. We might use that expression to describe the situation in regard to the press releases describing neuroscience research. If perchance some neuroscience study produces some very important finding, it will be hailed in a press release claiming some grand breakthrough. But if (as is true in the overwhelming majority of cases) a neuroscience study fails to be any example of a well-designed study following good research practices, or if the study fails to provide any decent evidence of anything, then it will often still get the same kind of "praise it to the sky" press release. 

clickbait hype for junk science

The latest evidence of this is to be found in a press release issued by a hospital in Spain. We have the grand-sounding title "Possible Foundations of Human Intelligence Observed for the First Time." The title is bunk, as are some of the claims made in the press release. 

The first sentence in the press release is this bogus claim: "A study led by Dr. Rodrigo Quian Quiroga has demonstrated how neurons in the human brain generate memories and establish narratives." It is soon followed by this equally fictional claim: "For the first time, it has been confirmed that, contrary to previous beliefs, individual neurons represent the concepts we learn, regardless of the context in which we encounter them." The claims are about a study that did nothing to establish such boasts. 

The next claim in the press release is this utterly groundless boast: 

"A study led by Dr. Rodrigo Quian Quiroga, group leader of the Neural Mechanisms of Perception and Memory Research Group at the Hospital del Mar Research Institute, has allowed scientists to observe for the first time how neurons in the human brain store memories independent of context in which they are acquired. Published in Cell Reports, the study confirms that neurons can distinguish objects or people regardless of their context, enabling the formation of higher and more abstract relationships, which constitutes the basis of human intelligence."

The rest of the press release tells us nothing to substantiate these bogus boasts. We hear about nine epilepsy patients who had microelectrodes implanted in their brains.   A general rule of thumb for experimental neuroscience studies is that any study using fewer than 15 or 20 subjects should be regarding as junk science, having used too few subjects for any decent statistical power to be produced.  The visual below illustrates the type of study group sizes that are needed in neuroscience experiments. 

neuroscience study group sizes

In studies such as this, scientists will pick  several hundred neurons to monitor, and they will try to measure activation rates of such neurons while a subject engages in some cognitive activity. The approach is profoundly misguided. There are billions of neurons in the brain, and all neurons fire at rates of about 1 time per second or more, as many as 200 times per second. If brains stored memories or brains were responsible for producing ideas or thinking, you could never verify that by monitoring the firing rate of several hundred neurons. You might see a slightly higher firing rate in some neurons of the several hundred neurons that you selected. Since you were examining no more than a millionth of the total neurons in the brain, this would never give you a warrant for thinking that you had got lucky, and that such a tiny fraction of the brain was responsible for storing a memory or recalling a memory or having an idea. 

When we look at the scientific paper, we find that it reports things consistent with the idea that the selected neurons had no real correlation with the mental activity of the subjects. We read this:

"We observe similar single-neuron responses to the same concepts in different tasks.  Neurons do not show conjunctive coding (i.e., responding only in specific contexts or tasks)." 

It is never justified to speak of single-neuron "responses" to a concept or an experience.  A single neuron does not respond to something a  person sees or recalls or thinks about. A neuron fires continuously at a rate of about 1 time per second or more (up to 200 times per second), with random variations (as shown in the visual at the end of this post). It is always misleading to try and suggest a stimulus and response relation between a neuron firing and something someone saw or thought of or recalled.  We have in the paper ridiculous sentences such as this: "Figure 2 shows an exemplary neuron from the left hippocampus that responded to Diego Topa (an Argentinian television host) but not to the actor Jackie Chan." All that is going here is scientists tracking random activity from a noisy variable source (a human neuron), and inappropriately calling that a response. A similar thing would be going on if someone spent many hours looking at birds in his front yard, and made statements such as this: "After three hours I noticed that a sparrow in my front yard responded to my change of television channels, by leaving a tree when I  changed to Channel 7." In the Figure 2 referred to in the quote above, we actually see the neuron firing both while the person was seeing Diego Topa and Jackie Chan, with there being merely a momentary blip (a little more firing activity) while Diego Topa was seen one time. Such momentary blips (very brief increases in firing activity) happen countless times a day to every neuron. It is laughable to try to portray one of these blips as a "response" to the observer seeing a photo of someone. This is like tracking someone coughing hundreds of times a day, and claiming that one of his coughs is a "response" to an image the person sees on a TV.  

In the paper the authors confess "our main result is the absence of evidence for significant differences." The subjects were shown different visual stimuli and asked to perform different tasks as about 700 of their neurons were being monitored.  No robust evidence was found of any variation in the firing activity of these neurons that can be meaningful correlated with the activities the person engaged in. The authors refer to "the lack of context modulations and conjunctive coding described here." We should laugh hard at the authors attempt to find a trace of differential response such as their statement that one neuron once or twice fired more often when a person saw an image of one actor. Given a long tracking of random firing activity from 700 neurons in nine subjects, you would always expect to find one neuron firing once or twice more when one thing was seen than another. 

But what do you do if you are an institution press release writer, and you have a study reporting essentially that it found nothing? Egged on by your superiors to hype at all costs, and protected by the fact that such press releases have no author name, you may lie like crazy, claiming that some grand epic accomplishment was made. 

It is a scandal that very sick epilepsy patients are being lured into participating in poorly designed studies such as this, using study group sizes that are so small that they cannot be regarded as reliable evidence for anything. Very sick epilepsy patients with drug-resistant epilepsy sometimes have electrodes put into their brains to evaluate where they should have brain surgery. But the type of microelectrodes used for a study like this are a different type of electrodes, and their implanting in a patient's brain is not surgically necessary. There are serious risks associated with the implanting of microelectrodes. In this case epilepsy patients may have suffered serious unnecessary risks for the sake of a poorly designed study using too small a study group size to ever produce a robust result. Very sick patients should not be put at unnecessary risk for the sake of junk science. 

immoral neuroscience research

The paper claims that "electrode locations were based exclusively on clinical criteria," but that does not specifically refer to the microelectrodes implanted in the brains of these very sick patients; and that claim does not amount to any claim that the number and insertion depth of all the electrodes and microelectrodes were based exclusively on clinical criteria.

Here is a quote from a scientific paper:

"The effects of penetrating microelectrode implantation on brain tissues according to the literature data...  are as follows:

  1. Disruption of the blood–brain barrier (BBB);
  2. Tissue deformation;
  3. Scarring of the brain tissue around the implant, i.e., gliosis 
  4. Chronic inflammation after microelectrode implantation;
  5. Neuronal cells loss."

Whenever this kind of Fake News is released, we should regard those  scientists who tolerate the groundless boasts about their work as being just as guilty of deceit as those who wrote the deceitful prose, because they failed to correct the misleading information. 

lying science press release

With a wink and a nod

Below is a visual (Figure 2) from a scientific paper that did single-cell recordings of the firings of individual neurons in monkeys. Each one of the vertical bars represents a spike in the firing rate of a neuron. There is no clear relation between the firing rate and the stimulus presented to the monkey,  The "clumpy-bursty" example was one cherry-picked to show the strongest evidence of response to the stimulus.  A visual like this makes clear that spikes or blips in the firing rate of a neuron occur randomly many times a day. It is deceptive to pick out a case where one of these blips occurs when the stimulus occurred, and to call such a blip a "response" to the stimulus. 

blips in neuron  firing rates

Studies like these can be done perfectly well with monkeys, as in this paper. It  an example of morally dubious research whenever such studies are done on human epilepsy patients, who should not be subjected to the unnecessary risks of such studies. 

Friday, March 21, 2025

Claimed Evidence for "Concept Cells" Is Just Noise-Mining Nonsense

 Quanta Magazine is a widely-read online magazine with slick graphics. On topics of science the magazine again and again is guilty of the most glaring failures.  The articles at Quanta Magazine often contain misleading prose, groundless boasts or the most glaring falsehoods. I discuss some examples of such poor journalism in my posts here and  here and here and here and here.

The latest piece of nonsense in Quanta Magazine is an article trying to persuade us that scientists have discovered "concept cells" in the brain. No such thing has occurred. What is mainly going on is noise mining,  the morally dubious exploitation of very sick epilepsy patients, and scientists trying to get citations and attention by wrongly applying unjustified nicknames to cells. 

The research discussed works like this:

(1) Electrodes are implanted in the brains of very sick epilepsy patients requiring surgery for epilepsy, supposedly for the sake of surgical evaluation on where to perform the surgery (although we should suspect that additional electrodes are being implanted so that this type of noise-mining research can be done). 

(2) The patients are shown some visual stimuli, and EEG readings of their brain waves are taken while they see this stimuli. 

(3) The data is then analyzed, with searches made for particular neurons that fired more often when some particular image was seen.  Scientists then make a triumphal declaration that a "concept cell" was found, on the basis of the claim that some neuron was firing more frequently than we would expect when some visual stimulus was seen. 

This is noise-mining, like someone searching 1000 photos of clouds looking for one that looks like the ghost of an animal.  Neurons in the brain fire continuously, at a rate between 1 time per second and 200 times per second. Anyone tracking the firing of 300 neurons while someone is seeing different things will be able to find a few neurons that seemed to fire more often when something was seen. Similarly, if someone records the ups and downs of 300 stocks on the New York Stock exchange, and tries to correlate them with the occurrence of images coming from his television set showing an old movie, he will be able to find a few stocks that went up or down more often when some particular image was displayed. But that would be mere noise-mining. 

It is never justified to speak of single-neuron "responses" to a concept or an experience.  A single neuron does not respond to something a  person sees or recalls or thinks about. A neuron fires continuously at a rate of about 1 time per second or more, with random variations. It is always misleading to try and suggest a stimulus and response relation between a neuron firing and something someone saw or thought of or recalled.  This is like tracking many flu-infected people who each cough hundreds of times a day, and boasting about having found some "concept coughs," claiming that some of the coughs are a "response" to an image a person sees on a TV.  

The main paper discussed is the late 2024 paper "Concept and location neurons in the human brain provide the 'what' and 'where' in memory formation." The paper does nothing to find any evidence of memories stored in brains. All that is going is noise-mining of 3681 neuron firings in 13 epilepsy patients who had electrodes implanted in their brains. 

We should have no trust in the statistical analysis done in the paper, which is largely dependent upon a large body of programming code that looks like it is poorly written, and is performing all kinds of obscure or arbitrary convolutions and manipulations of data. You can see the programming code here. The EEG data is being processed in many a strange way, and is being passed through all kinds of contortion processes including many  doubly-nested loops doing God-only-knows-what, as in this example:

for k=1:numXbins

    for j=1:numYbins

        n(k,j)= sum ( wavs(:,k) <= ybins(j)+ybinSize/2 & wavs(:,k) > ybins(j)-ybinSize/2);

    end

end

No peer reviewer could ever untangle the programmatic "witches' brew" that is going on in the programming code of this paper. 

torturing data until it confesses

 A look at the peer reviewer comments on the paper gives us some hints about the paper's defects. One peer-reviewer asks this:

"These recordings come from epilepsy patients. How were possible epilepsy-related confounds mitigated?"

Here's what this comment refers to: epilepsy patients scheduled for surgery have all kinds of weird brain wave anomalies cropping up in their brain waves as recorded by EEG devices.  The possibilities for getting false alarms from EEG readings from epilepsy patients is endless. The paper authors respond to this question in an unconvincing way, by claiming that they were using EEG analysis software that did something to reduce such a problem. It is not a convincing response. 

When we read calculations of p-values in papers like this, we typically get no detailed discussion of how such a p-value was computed. We should have little trust in the accuracy of the calculated p-value. In the case of this paper, one of the peer reviewers says that he did his own calculation, and got a p-value number drastically different from  one of the p-values published in the paper.  

brain wave noise mining
The game of "keep torturing the data until it confesses"

This experiment was based on nonsensical assumptions.  The brain has billions of neurons and trillions of synapses. There never was any reason to believe that studying the firing rate of any single neuron  during the observation of sights by subjects would produce any evidence that such a neuron encodes or recognizes or represents or is sensitive to any concept. The idea that you would get meaningful evidence of such a thing from analyzing the firing of only 3681  randomly selected neurons (from a brain of billions of neurons) never made any sense, particularly given the extremely large random variations in the firings of noisy neurons. If an individual neuron encoded a concept, we would expect that an experiment such as this would have less than 1 chance in a million of success, since 3681 is less than a millionth of the total number of neurons in a brain. 

In any study in which subjects are moving muscles, you can never assume that some neuron has some connection to a concept because greater firing activity occurred when that concept was displayed or chosen.  It is well-known that muscle movements abundantly contaminate EEG readings that indicate how much neurons are firing. So in any study in which subjects are not perfectly immobile, you have no way of knowing whether some increased neuron firing is merely due to some increase or difference in muscle movement. In this study subjects were not perfectly immobile when the EEG readings occurred. They were instead performing activities with their hands. For example, we read, "The participant was asked to confirm every image location by tapping it within the presentation time window (1.5–3.5 s)."

The idea of a concept cell is nonsense. No one has any coherent idea of how a single cell could represent a concept or why a cell would have a tendency to respond more frequently when a viewer is exposed to just one concept. Since the  paper is so dependent upon black-box spaghetti code that is programmatically fooling around with their gathered data in many strange and tangled ways, no one should have any confidence that evidence of a "concept cell" was found. 

Below is a visual (Figure 2) from a scientific paper that did single-cell recordings of the firings of individual neurons in monkeys. Each one of the vertical bars represents a spike in the firing rate of a neuron. There is no clear relation between the firing rate and the stimulus presented to the monkey,  The "clumpy-bursty" example was one cherry-picked to show the strongest evidence of response to the stimulus.  A visual like this makes clear that spikes or blips in the firing rate of a neuron occur randomly many times a day. It is deceptive to pick out a case where one of these blips occurs when the stimulus occurred, and to call such a blip a "response" to the stimulus. But such a deception is what is occurring in papers claiming to have found "concept cells." 

blips in neuron firing rates

The paper discussed above ("Concept and location neurons in the human brain provide the 'what' and 'where' in memory formation")  gives us no assertion that the microelectrodes implanted in the brains of these very sick epilepsy patients were inserted only for medical reasons, to evaluate where they should have surgery. Since we have got no such assertion, we should suspect that one or more of the microelectrodes were unnecessarily implanted in the brains of very sick patients, for the sake of this poor-quality study based on nonsensical assumptions. Implantation of microelectrodes in the brain comes with very serious risks.  People requiring epilepsy surgery are very sick people who should not be put at higher risk for the sake of low-quality research such as this. 

The paper discussed above implanted many microelectrodes in epilepsy patients. The type of electrode normally used for surgical evaluation of epilepsy patients is a much larger type of electrode called a macroelectrode. A scientific paper tells us, "Sixty-five years after single units were first recorded in the human brain, there remain no established clinical indications for microelectrode recordings in the presurgical evaluation of patients with epilepsy (Cash and Hochberg, 2015)." In other words, there is no medical justification for implanting microelectrodes in the brains of epilepsy patients. The paper tells us that the microelectrodes were "inserted through the hollow clinical macro electrodes, and protruding from the tips by ~4 mm." This was medically unnecessary and potentially hazardous insertion of many wires into the brains of very sick patients.  We seem to have here some very sick patients being put at needless risk merely so that junk science can be produced. 

reckless neuroscientist

Here is a quote from a scientific paper:

"The effects of penetrating microelectrode implantation on brain tissues according to the literature data...  are as follows:

  1. Disruption of the blood–brain barrier (BBB);
  2. Tissue deformation;
  3. Scarring of the brain tissue around the implant, i.e., gliosis 
  4. Chronic inflammation after microelectrode implantation;
  5. Neuronal cells loss."
I strongly advise any people who participated in any brain scanning experiment or any neuroscience experiment involving electrode implants to permanently keep very careful records of their participation, to find out and write down the name of the scientific paper corresponding to the study, to write down and keep the names of any scientists or helpers they were involved with, to permanently keep a copy of any forms they signed, and to keep a very careful log of any health problems they ever have. Such information may be useful should such a person decide to file a lawsuit or a claim seeking monetary damages. 

Postscript: The term "gnostic cells" has sometimes been used to mean the same thing as "concept cells."

More noise-mining nonsense is found in the recent paper "Lack of context modulation in human single neuron responses in the medial temporal lobe," which you can read here. This time the study group is even smaller, consisting of only 9 very sick patients.  The authors have failed to make their code publicly available through any easy access method, as if they were embarrassed by their programming. But using the link here you can download their code as a .zip file, scan the .zip file for viruses, and then extract it, which is a laborious way to have to inspect code. I did that, and found the usual very-poorly-documented spaghetti code programming horror that you typically find in projects like this. We have undocumented loops like the one below, doing some unfathomable rigmarole contortions of the brain wave data:

for iresp=1:size(resp,2)
    if ~isempty(resp(iresp).trecall_phasic_ms)
        resp_rec = resp_rec + 1;
        active_cluster = resp(iresp).spike_times_Rec;
        phasic_recall = resp(iresp).trecall_phasic_ms;
        ntrials(1) = size(active_cluster{resp(iresp).responsive_Storiesindex(1)},1);
        ntrials(2) = size(active_cluster{resp(iresp).responsive_Storiesindex(2)},1);
        strength_pair = NaN*ones(max(ntrials),2);
    
        equiv_strength(resp_rec).chan = resp(iresp).channel_number;
        equiv_strength(resp_rec).class = resp(iresp).cluster;
        equiv_strength(resp_rec).pair = resp(iresp).responsive_Storiesindex;
            
        for istim=1:2 
            phas_vec = phasic_recall{resp(iresp).responsive_Storiesindex(istim)};
            spikes1 = active_cluster{resp(iresp).responsive_Storiesindex(istim)};
            spikes1 = arrayfun(@(k) spikes1{k}-phas_vec(k),[1:length(phas_vec)]','UniformOutput',false);
            strength_pair(1:ntrials(istim),istim) = cell2mat(cellfun(@(x) sum((x< twin_off) & (x> twin_on)),spikes1,'UniformOutput',0));
        end
            
    
        nsamp = min(ntrials);
        equiv_strength(resp_rec).samples = ntrials;
        equiv_strength(resp_rec).meandiff_Hz = (diff(nanmean(strength_pair)))/((twin_off-twin_on)/1000);
        equiv_strength(resp_rec).delta = sqrt(2/nsamp*(norminv(alpha)+norminv(alpha/2))^2);
        [equiv_strength(resp_rec).test_resu, equiv_strength(resp_rec).pval, equiv_strength(resp_rec).pooledSD, equiv_strength(resp_rec).meandiff] = TOST_2023(strength_pair(~isnan(strength_pair(:,1)),1), strength_pair(~isnan(strength_pair(:,2)),2), 'welch',equiv_strength(resp_rec).delta,alpha);
    end
end

And we have the equally ugly unfathomable bit of monkey business below:

for ii=1:length(spikes)
        if iscell(spikes{ii})
            all_spks=cell2mat(spikes{ii}');
        else
            all_spks=spikes{ii}(:);
        end

        spikes_tot=all_spks(all_spks < tmax_epoch+half_ancho_gauss & all_spks > tmin_epoch-half_ancho_gauss);
        spike_timeline = hist(spikes_tot,(tmin_epoch-half_ancho_gauss:sample_period:tmax_epoch+half_ancho_gauss))/ntrials(ii);
        n_spike_timeline = length(spike_timeline); %should be the same length as ejex
        integ_timeline_stim = conv(spike_timeline, int_window);
        integ_timeline_stim_cut = integ_timeline_stim(round(half_ancho_gauss/sample_period)+1:n_spike_timeline+round(half_ancho_gauss/sample_period));
        aver_fr{ii} =  smooth(integ_timeline_stim_cut(which_times),smooth_bin);

        % subplot(length(spikes),1,ii)
        % plot(ejex(which_times(1:downs:end)),aver_fr{ii}(1:downs:end))
        % maxi(ii) = max(aver_fr{ii});
    end  

I can merely say the more time a programmer spends looking at the programming code used by this paper, the less confidence he will have that the paper did anything to establish the existence of "concept cells." This is black box "witches' brew" monkeying around with brain wave data that is best described with the phrase "they kept torturing the data until it confessed in the weakest whisper."

A visual from the paper gives you the type of data that was being tortured to try to get something. Random cases of more noise blips from noisy and extremely variable neurons (during a few seconds) are being passed off as "concept responses." It's like someone tracking each and every noise blip from a nearby street construction crew using a jackhammer,  and trying to correlate particular noise spikes with images appearing on his TV set. That would be a very silly case of noise mining, and what is going on in this paper is just as silly. 


One of the authors of this poor-quality paper is Rodrigo Quian Quiroga, who has long been quoted as making a misleading claim about a "Jennifer Aniston" concept cell.  For example:
  • In a 2017 article "Concept cells: the building blocks of declarative memory functions" by  Quian Quiroga, he incorrectly stated, "One of the first such neurons found in the hippocampus fired to seven different pictures of the actress Jennifer Aniston and not to 80 other pictures of known and unknown people, animals and places." This was a claim that did not match the data in his 2005 paper where we have in Figure 1A a visual depiction of more than 50 firings of that neuron when the subject was shown a picture other than Jennifer Aniston.
  • In Figure 1 of the year 2020 "Searching for the neural correlates of human intelligence" article by Quian Quiroga, he misleadingly states that the Jennifer Aniston neuron "did not respond to about 80 pictures of other persons," a claim which does not match the data in his 2005 paper where we have in Figure 1A a visual depiction of more than 50 firings of that neuron when the subject was shown a picture other than Jennifer Aniston.  
  • In a 2025 Salon article with many misstatements,  Quian Quiroga made this incorrect statement: "'Twenty years ago … I was doing experiments with a patient, and then I showed many pictures of Jennifer Aniston, and I found a neuron that responded only to her and to nothing else...It was very clear that in an area called the hippocampus that is known to be critical for memory, we have neurons that represent, in this case, specific people, or in general, specific concepts. "  The claim does not match what was reported in Quian Quiroga's 2005 paper, where  we have in Figure 1A a visual depiction of more than 50 firings of that neuron when the subject was shown a picture other than Jennifer Aniston.  
 In fact, Figure 1A of the 2005 paper shows that the famed "Jennifer Aniston neuron" did fire more than seven times when a picture of a basketball player was shown, that it did fire more than seven times when a picture of another basketball player was shown, that it did fire more than five times when a picture of a snake was shown, and that it did fire more than six times when a picture of the Leaning Tower of Pisa was shown. The paper says this: "To hold their attention, patients had to perform a simple task during all sessions (indicating with a key press whether a human face was present in the image)."  It is known that the muscle movements can abundantly affect EEG readings and whether a neuron fires. A difference between key presses when the Jennifer Aniston picture was shown and things other than faces were shown can easily account for why one neuron may have fired differently when pictures of Jennifer were shown, without any need at all to evoke an idea of a "concept cell" for Jennifer Aniston. Maybe Quian Quiroga's misstatements on his "Jennifer Aniston neuron" had something to do with the fact that he later managed to get a book deal, a deal for a book with a title mentioning his claimed "Jennifer Aniston" neuron. 

When he discusses this "Jennifer Aniston neuron" outside of the original paper, Quian Quiroga seems to never mention that the subject with that neuron was asked to press a button whenever he saw a face, and that muscle movements are known to increase brain wave spikes picked up by electrodes or EEG devices.  That seems like the "secret sauce" behind his "Jennifer Aniston" neuron. 

There is nothing very impressive about this case of the neuron's firing more often while someone saw a few pictures of Jennifer Aniston. While unlikely to occur on any one day, it is the kind of result you would expect an eager noise miner to produce after spending very long periods of time looking for some result better than chance in a dataset of random data. Similarly, if someone is very eager to find a cloud shape looking like the ghost of an animal, and he spends day after day scanning photos of clouds looking for such a thing, he will probably find one or two clouds that look rather like animal ghosts. Activity like this is correctly described as misguided noise-mining "Jesus in my toast" pareidolia, aided by misstatements in which the meager result is described in a misleading way. 

Tuesday, July 9, 2024

No, Noise Miners, Neurons Don't Encode Words

Every year the journal Nature publishes many junk science neuroscience papers guilty of very bad examples of Questionable Research Practices. It is a huge mistake for anyone to think that the most prestigious journals such as Cell and Nature only publish high-quality neuroscience research. When it comes to neuroscience research, the standards of such "big name" journals are very low. The journal Nature also regularly publishes false-headline articles about neuroscience research, articles with some of the most misleading clickbait boasts to be found anywhere. Let us look at the latest example of a groundless boast the journal Nature is peddling. It is the unfounded  claim that someone discovered "neurons that encode words’ meaning."  The idea is nonsensical. No one has any idea of how a neuron could possibly encode the meaning of a word. 

In the Nature article peddling this boast, we have a subtitle of "For the first time, scientists identify individual brain cells linked to the linguistic essence of a word." Always distrust anyone claiming to have done something in the field of neuroscience "for the first time." What it generally means is some research making some boast that has not been reproduced by other scientists.  We read a description of what was going on:

"But Williams and his colleagues found a unique opportunity to look at how individual neurons encode language in real time. His group recruited 10 people about to undergo surgery for epilepsy, each of whom had had electrodes implanted in their brains to determine the source of their seizures. The electrodes allowed the researchers to record activity from around 300 neurons in each person’s prefrontal cortex.

As participants listened to multiple short sentences containing a total of around 450 words, the scientists recorded which neurons fired and when. Williams says that around two or three distinct neurons lit up for each word, although he points out that the team recorded only the activity of a tiny fraction of the prefrontal cortex’s billions of neurons."

This is noise-mining. Neurons in the brain fire continuously, at a rate between 1 time per second and 200 times per second. Anyone tracking the firing of 300 neurons while someone is listening to speech will be able to find a few neurons that seemed to fire more often when something was said. Similarly, if someone records the ups and downs of 300 stocks on the New York Stock exchange, and tries to correlate them with the occurrence of words coming from his television set showing an old movie, he will be able to find a few stocks that went up or down more often when some particular word was spoken. But that would be mere noise-mining. 

The diagram below is from the scientific paper here ("Neuronal firing rates diverge during REM and homogenize during non-REM").  The authors say that they sorted neuron rates into five quintiles. Evidently neurons fire in a fluctuating manner at a rate between  about 1 time per second (the top line) and about 100 times per second (the bottom line). This is just the kind of noisy, fluctuating data that noise-miners love to have. Anyone analyzing data so random and fluctuating can find some neurons that seem to fire more often when compared to some unrelated factor such as a word someone is hearing. 

neuron firing rates

The Nature article is promoting the paper "Semantic encoding during language comprehension at single-cell resolution." Looking at the paper, I quickly find much use of misleading language. We read this:

"We observed that many of the neurons responded selectively to specific word meanings. The selectivity or ‘tuning’ of neurons reflects the degree to which they respond to words denoting particular meanings (that is, words that belong to specific semantic domains)."

Never trust a physical scientist using the word "selectively" or "selection." We have a 160-year history of scientists using the word "selection" in a misleading way, which began with Charles Darwin coining the term "natural selection" to refer to a blind, mindless process that was not actually selection. "Selection" is a word meaning a choice by a conscious agent. The neurons referred to above were in no sense selecting anything. It was merely allegedly found that some of these neurons were firing more often when certain words were spoken. This is exactly what we would expect to find by chance, given 300 random neurons with random firings that were compared to the playing of 450 random words. It is no evidence at all of either encoding or selection going on in neurons. All that's going on here is noise-mining.  You could find a similar result by having a computer program with voice recognition abilities compare words coming from one of your television sets with words spoken when some other TV in your home played some television series shown on another channel.  After data collection and automatic programmatic analysis, it would be found that some type of words might be heard more often on the second channel when some particular word was spoken on the first channel. There would be no causal relation involved, and the result would be meaningless noise-mining.  

To help facilitate their noise-mining, the authors of the paper have "greased the wheels" by introducing something they call "semantic domains." Since the authors were free to arbitrarily put words in whatever "semantic domains" they wished, this helped them to see what they were hoping to see. Throughout the paper, verbs and nouns are used in a misleading way. We hear of the "selection" and "selectivity" of neurons that were not selecting anything, and we hear the claim that "many neurons distinguished words from nonwords," although no evidence has been provided of any actual distinguishing or recognition.  What's going on is that the authors are merely crunching the random data of neuron firings, and correlating some cases of more frequent firings with the simultaneous occurrence of spoken words.  This is being passed off as neurons "distinguishing" something or "selecting" something.  Similar nonsense would be going on if I tracked the random ups and downs of 300 stocks, correlating such data with 400 words coming out of my TV set while an old movie played, and then said that certain stocks on the stock exchange "selected" or "distinguished" particular words. 

Our authors then move on to misusing the word "representations," a word that today's neuroscientists are constantly misusing, in cases where they have zero robust evidence that any such thing as a representation is occurring.  No evidence has been provided here of brains encoding words or recognizing words or selecting words or distinguishing words or representing. All that has gone on is noise-mining. 

A look at the programming code used for this experiment shows all kinds of arbitrary data fiddling going on, what smells like a byzantine rigmarole affair of "keep torturing the data until it confesses in the weakest voice."  Opening up the files using the link above, an experienced programmer like me can sniff many a sign of hard-to-justify programmatic convolutions going on, with the data being very frequently passed through all kinds of weird loops that are doing God-only-knows-what.  I very much doubt that any of the programmers of this code or any of the authors of the paper fully understand what was going on with these data manipulations. Graphs in the paper are based not on the original raw data gathered from brains, but the output after such data was programmatically manipulated in many a strange and arbitrary way.  

neuroscience analysis pathway

This experiment was based on nonsensical assumptions.  The brain has billions of neurons and trillions of synapses. There never was any reason to believe that studying the firing of any single neuron  during the hearing of words by subjects would produce any evidence that such a neuron encodes or recognizes or represents or is sensitive to any word. The idea that you would get meaningful evidence of such a thing from analyzing the firing of a few hundred randomly selected neurons (from a brain of billions of neurons) never made any sense, particularly given the extremely large random variations in the firings of noisy neurons.  

Normally, noise-mining is a harmless bit of nonsense. For example, someone may try to analyze the ups and downs of summer temperatures and windspeeds in coastal China and try to correlate them with the wins and losses of baseball teams in the United States, maybe finding one or two teams that seem to perform better when it is windy or warm in coastal China.  That's harmless nonsense. But in this case the authors may not merely have engaged in harmless nonsense.

A medical page here describes how electrodes are implanted to detect where seizures come from. It says this:

"We are going to place several (~10-15) electrodes into your brain. These electrodes are thin, floppy wires about the thickness of a spaghetti noodle."

But what is described by the "Semantic encoding during language comprehension at single-cell resolution" paper I am discussing is something vastly more than what is mentioned above: the implanting of a very large number of microelectrodes capable of recording the activity of individual neurons. Below is only a small part of the description of how the subjects seemed to undergo additional electrode implanting, with more than 900 microelectrodes being implanted into the brain (the "cortical ribbon" refers to the cortex of the brain):

"For the silicon microelectrode recordings, sterile Neuropixels probes31 (version 1.0-S, IMEC, ethylene oxide sterilized by BioSeal) were advanced into the cortical ribbon with a manipulator connected to a ROSA ONE Brain (Zimmer Biomet) robotic arm. The probes (width: 70 µm, length: 10 mm, thickness: 100 µm) consisted of 960 contact sites (384 preselected recording channels) that were laid out in a chequerboard pattern."

The news article in Nature says, "His group recruited ten people about to undergo surgery for epilepsy, each of whom had had electrodes implanted in their brains to determine the source of their seizures." But the scientific paper makes no mention of epilepsy or seizures. Instead it tells us that "All participants included in the study were scheduled to undergo planned awake intraoperative neurophysiology and single-neuronal recordings for deep brain stimulation targeting."  A table of the paper lists only patient diagnoses other than epilepsy: Parkinson's disease, essential tremor and cervical dystonia. Oops, it seems the journal Nature can't get its story straight. 

Deep brain stimulation is sometimes used for Parkinson's disease, although it is a risky technique of dubious value (the paper here reporting a 13% incidence of "serious adverse effects" with such a treatment). Also the meta-analysis here finds that using micro-electrodes to try to analyze places for surgery  does not improve surgical outcomes, telling us, "This meta-analysis shows that there is no difference in clinical outcome between a surgical technique with and without MER [Microelectrode recording]."  Deep-brain stimulation for Parkinson's typically involves targeting regions deep in the brain, regions other than the cortex: the thalamus, the subthalmic nucleus, and the globus pallidus. But the paper I am criticizing got data from cortex regions far away from such regions. It tells us, "Single-neuron recordings were obtained from the left language-dominant prefrontal cortex." 

We are told that decisions about the electrode insertions "were made independently of any study consideration," but you may reasonably doubt such a claim if the unspecified persons making such decisions were the same people benefiting from the publication of the paper. In the medical world there is a massive history of doctors claiming without much credibility to have made treatment decisions or recommendations "independently" of some financial or professional benefit they may derive from such recommendations or decisions. For example, innumerable doctors claimed (without much credibility) to have recommended opioid prescriptions "independently" of financial gain they got from such recommendations. Similarly, doctors at clinics with profitable fancy scanners may claim to recommend expensive scans "independently" of the doctor's  financial benefits from such scans (a claim we should doubt). And many doctors often recommend unnecessary surgery treatments profitable for them, and claim to have reached such recommendations "independently" of financial profits the doctors get from such treatment; but you should often be skeptical of such claims of decisions made independently of the doctor's financial benefits.  

We may wonder if the ten subjects each getting hundreds of microelectrode implants underwent very significant risk largely for the sake of a badly conceived experiment that did nothing to provide robust evidence about neurons and cognition. A scientific paper tells us, "Sixty-five years after single units were first recorded in the human brain, there remain no established clinical indications for microelectrode recordings in the presurgical evaluation of patients with epilepsy (Cash and Hochberg, 2015)." In other words, there is no medical justification for implanting microelectrodes in the brains of epilepsy patients.

immoral neuroscience

Here is a quote from a scientific paper:

"The effects of penetrating microelectrode implantation on brain tissues according to the literature data...  are as follows:

  1. Disruption of the blood–brain barrier (BBB);
  2. Tissue deformation;
  3. Scarring of the brain tissue around the implant, i.e., gliosis 
  4. Chronic inflammation after microelectrode implantation;
  5. Neuronal cells loss."
I strongly advise any people who participated in any brain scanning experiment or any neuroscience experiment involving electrode implants to permanently keep very careful records of their participation, to find out and write down the name of the scientific paper corresponding to the study, to write down and keep the names of any scientists or helpers they were involved with, to permanently keep a copy of any forms they signed, and to keep a very careful log of any health problems they ever have. Such information may be useful should such a person decide to file a lawsuit.

There is zero robust evidence of any kind of encoding going on in the brain other than the genetic coding that goes on DNA, which is merely low-level chemical coding in which amino acids are represented.  Any claims to the contrary will not hold up to careful scrutiny, and will typically be found to be appeals to poorly designed experiments engaging in Questionable Research Practices, experiments not producing results that were well-replicated. 

The structure of human neurons has not changed in many thousands of years. Conversely, words in a language have typically only been used for centuries. Words have meanings that often gradually change from decade to decade.  For example, the English word "chip" has multiple meanings, mostly meanings that arose relatively recently.  A person using the phrase "chip" may refer to a computer component, a plastic poker chip, or a potato chip, all human inventions of recent centuries. The English word "hack" now has a computer-related meaning it did not have when I was born, and the English word "bug" now has two meanings it did not have in 1930, one referring to a software defect and the other referring to electronic surveillance. The idea that neurons (with structures unchanged in 5000 years) encode human words (mostly less than thousands of years old and often with meanings only decades old) makes no sense.  For more on this, see my post "Young Age of Languages Contradicts Claims of Neural Storage of Linguistic Information." 

The encoding of words occurs in things such as dictionaries, which describe the multiple meanings of words. The encoding of a word is something far more complicated than merely a higher response rate. My eyebrows may raise if I am swimming and you shout, "Shark!" But that would not be a case of my eyebrows encoding the word "shark." And similarly, you would not show a neuron encoded a word if you gave data suggesting the neuron fired more often when the word was spoken.

Some actual encoding of words

Postscript: Another noise-mining paper ("Default mode network electrophysiological dynamics and causal role in creative thinking") fails to provide any robust evidence that brains produce creative thinking, but does provide more reasons for suspecting that patients are being put at risk for the sake of junk science papers.  We have another paper using too-small study group sizes (13 patients total, with study group sizes such as 9 and 10 subjects).  No blinding protocol was used, a necessity for any study like this to be taken seriously. The patients were intractable epilepsy patients due for brain surgery, but we are told  that "the electrodes  were selected based on anatomical and clinical considerations (not part of the suspected seizure onset zone)," We may wonder whether the patients had electrodes inserted other than what was necessary to determine where they should have surgery to help their seizures. We hear in the paper of brain-zapping as part of the experiment, which can produce seizures in epileptic patients. 15 subjects per study group is the minimum for any experimental study seeking correlation evidence, and for most effect sizes the required study group size is much higher (30 or more). A 2021 paper ("Increasing the statistical power of animal experiments with historical control data" by V. Bonapersona et. al. ) tells us, "For a common effect size of Hedge’s g= 0.5 (Welch’s independent samples t-test, α=0.05), ten animals per group would correspond to a statistical power of 18%, 30 animals per group to 48% power and 65 animals per group to 81% power."  80% statistical power is regarded as good, and 18% statistical power is very weak statistical power, with a high likelihood of a false alarm. Again we may sadly wonder how many very sick patients are put at risk for noise-mining junk science papers. 

Another recent paper senselessly endangering very sick epilepsy patients is the low-quality paper "Distinct neuronal populations in the human brain combine content and context," a very misleading title. We have microwire implants put in very sick epilepsy patients for the sake of a poorly designed with an insufficient study group size (only 16) to have any weight as evidence. The authors confess in their supplemental information that they failed to do a sample size calculation. We are told there was informed consent, but are not given no link to the document that was signed. No claim is made that the microwire implants were made only for medically necessary purposes.