When writing up some scientific paper that may involve either experimental research or theorizing, a scientist often may think to himself questions such as "Is there some way to frame this work so that it sounds like important work worthy of publication?" or "Is there some way to spin this work so that it sounds like important work worthy of being cited, so that my citation count will increase?" But a scientist willing to "think big" may be more ambitious, and ask himself: "Is there some way to spin this work so that it sounds like something I could parlay into a book deal?"
There are two main types of scientists who try to parlay their work into book deals: the "grand theory" scientist and the experimental research scientist. The "grand theory" scientist is often someone thinking: how can I make my theory into a best-selling book?
The "grand theory" scientist trying to become a best-selling author is someone we cannot trust to accurately summarize facts and accurately report on reality, because he is so very badly biased. Such a scientist tends to report everything in a way that tries to make his grand theory seem credible.
We might call neuroscientist Michael W. Cole one of these "grand theory" scientists, except that there's nothing very grand at all about the theory he has recently been hawking while promoting his recent book. It is the theory that the human mind is explained by "brain flows." There's nothing very new or exciting here. Cole is the author of a recent book entitled "Brain Flows: How Network Dynamics Compose the Human Mind."
Cole has a blog site entitled "Neural Flows" devoted to pitching the erroneous idea that brain flows explain the human mind. Here are some recent posts at that site: - "Emotions as global low-dimensional brain flow patterns": this is a vacuous post making no substantive argument and making no reference to any neuroscience studies. We have ridiculous-sounding jargon-stuffed gobbledygook such as "I posit that emotions are global low-dimensional information-framing brain flow attractors."
- "Fluidized brain flows and the dynamics of consciousness": We read, "The thought I had while watching that video is that fluidized sand is an excellent model of brain flow dynamics...Like sand, the brain is composed of many physically separate objects (cells) that interact physically (via synapses and electric fields)." This sounds nonsensical, because cells are enormously organized components (unlike grains of sand that are simple particles), and no electricity passes between grains of sand in a flow of sand. We read, "My idea was that the primary purpose of the brain’s pervasive spontaneous activity may be to keep the brain in a fluidized state." The brain is not in a fluidized state. Like trees locked into place by their roots, the neurons in the brain are locked into place by all the dendrites and synapses that neurons are entangled with. We read the claim that "a series of studies have found that there is more spontaneous activity throughout human (and other animal) brains during consciousness than during a variety of non-conscious states." To the contrary, as discussed here, neurons fire just as much during sleep as they do when people are awake; and that is one of many very many reasons for thinking that the brain is not the source of the human mind. The comparison in this post between sand flow and brains flows is laughable.
- "What’s generative about generative network neuroscience." We have this boast: "In a 2024 study, my lab used activity flow modeling to show that distributed flows from other brain areas were causally sufficient to generate face selectivity in the fusiform face area." The reference is to an unimpressive paper that merely does a whole bunch of arbitrary analytics on some brain scanning data gathered by others, some analysis so convoluted that we seem to end up with no robust evidence for anything. Claims about "face selectivity in the fusiform face area" are not well-justified, as I discuss here.
- "Generative network neuroscience." This is a post making this dull-sounding boast: "We found that, indeed, resting-state functional connections are equivalent in some fundamental ways to model connectivity weights."
- "Enhancing scientific inference with evidence quality maps." Cole suggests making scientific graphs with nodes and links (something already done) and then grandly boasts, "I expect – like Tim Berners-Lee’s 1989 [World-Wide] Web proposal – that the ideas shared here will have an impact well beyond scientific practices."
There's nothing in these posts that substantiates his claim that "network dynamics compose the human mind." An excerpt from the book also fails to substantiate the claim. He complains that it's "like we’ve been doing neuroscience research with our hands tied behind our backs" because people haven't been concentrating on "brain flows" the way he has. He incorrectly states that "abstract task rule representations, such as 'if both items are the same,' have been identified within prefrontal cortex (and elsewhere). " No such representations have been discovered, and claims of such discoveries are examples of "Jesus in my toast" pareidolia. Unjustified claims about finding "representations" in brains are an epidemic in today's neuroscience literature. Cole incorrectly states, "This brain region is termed the fusiform face area, and it is more active when a participant sees a face relative to seeing other visual categories (such as a house or tool)," linking to the low-quality paper here (using a way-too-small study group size).
Then there's a long interview with Cole, in which he seems to ramble on and on and wander around in the woods, without ever giving us a compelling-sounding quote. We do not seem to get any quote from Cole backing up in any substantive way the claim that "network dynamics compose the human mind."
There's a good way to test the idea that "brain flows" explain human cognition. We can consider the question: what type of condition or operation produces the greatest change in brain flows, and what is the effect of such a condition or operation? If brain flows explain human cognition, we would expect that such a condition or operation would have the most enormous negative effect on human cognition.
The type of condition that most affects the flow of electricity in the brain is the loss of the corpus callosum. The corpus callosum is a bundle of fibers that connect the left hemisphere of the brain and the right hemisphere of the brain.
There are two ways in which such a condition can arise. The first way is if the corpus callosum fails to ever form during development. That is called agenesis of the corpus callosum. People lacking a corpus callosum have basically two separate brains inside their skull. Does this result in two minds, as we would expect under the theory that the brain makes the mind? No, people lacking a corpus callosum have a single, unified mind.
Agnesis means a failure of something in a developing child during a mother's pregnancy. The paper here is entitled "Outcomes Associated With Isolated Agenesis of the Corpus Callosum: A Meta-analysis." The paper distinguishes between what it calls "cACC" and "pACC," defining cACC as complete agenesis of the corpus callosum (in other words, the total failure of the corpus callosum to appear) and defining pACC as partial aegnesis of the corpus callosum (partial failure of the corpus callosum to appear). The paper gives us these statistics, telling us that in only a relatively small minority of cases of a complete congenital absence of the corpus callosum are there cognitive problems:
"In cACC, chromosomal anomalies occurred in 4.81% (95% confidence interval [CI], 2.2–8.4) of the cases. Gross and fine motor control were abnormal in 4.40% (95% CI, 0.6–11.3) and 10.98% (95% CI, 4.1–20.6) of the cases, respectively, whereas 6.80% (95% CI, 1.7–14.9) presented with epilepsy. Abnormal cognitive status occurred in 15.16% (95% CI, 6.9–25.9) of cases. In partial ACC, the rate of chromosomal anomalies was 7.45% (95% CI, 2.0–15.9). Fine motor control was affected in 11.74% (95% CI, 0.9–32.1) of the cases, and 16.11% (95% CI, 2.5–38.2) presented with epilepsy. Cognitive status was affected in 17.25% (95% CI, 3.0–39.7) of cases."
So in only about 16% of the subjects with a complete lack of a corpus callosum was there an abnormal cognitive status. These cACC (complete agenesis of the corpus callosum) people were basically people with two separate brains in their skulls. But most of them apparently had normal unified minds, since the paper says that only 15% of them had an abnormal cognitive status.
"Case I. — Dr. Alexander Bruce reports a man of ordinary intelligence and good character, and who, for thirteen years, did the work of a porter with perfect satisfaction, and exhibited no notable peculiarities. Yet in this man the corpus callosum was completely absent (23).
Case II. — Malinverni reports a soldier, aged 30 years, of ordinary intelligence, but with a slight tendency to melancholia, who had complete absence of the corpus callosum (24).
Case III. — Eichler reports a laborer, 43 years of age, married, diligent and capable, a good husband, sober and quiet, and could read and write, yet he had no corpus callosum, and had other important malformations of the brain (25)."
We have three cases of people with no corpus callosum, meaning that they had two separated hemispheres of the brain. But in each case their mind seemed normal.
Sometimes to prevent seizures, the entire corpus callosum is surgically severed. This is sometimes called a split brain operation. The operation leaves patients with a single unified self. Insinuations to the contrary sometimes made by materialists are an example of severe deception.
Physician Michael Egnor states the following about Sperry's research:
"The neuroscientist Roger Sperry studied scores of split-brain patients. He found, surprisingly, that in ordinary life the patients showed little effect. Each patient was still one person. The intellect and will – the capacity to have abstract thought and to choose – remained unified. Only by meticulous testing could Sperry find any differences: their perceptions were altered by the surgery. Sensations – elicited by touch or vision – could be presented to one hemisphere of the brain, and not be experienced in the other hemisphere. Speech production is associated with the left hemisphere of the brain; patients could not name an object presented to the right hemisphere (via the left visual field). Yet they could point to the object with their left hand (which is controlled by the right hemisphere). The most remarkable result of Sperry’s Nobel Prize–winning work was that the person’s intellect and will – what we might call the soul – remained undivided. The brain can be cut in half, but the intellect and will cannot. The intellect and will are metaphysically simple."
The actual facts about split-brain surgery are related here by a surgeon who has performed such an operation. He states this about split-brain patients:
"After the surgery they are unaffected in everyday life, except for the diminished seizures. They are one person after the surgery, as they were before."
The surgeon states: "In a rational scientific community in which evidence and reason held sway, split-brain surgery would be hailed as compelling evidence for dualism and the immateriality of the intellect and will." One thing is for sure: the cases we have for loss of the corpus callosum and preservation of mental function are cases that very much discredit Michael W. Cole's claim that "brain flows" explain human minds. It seems that human minds work just fine when brain flows are greatly reduced, by the loss of the corpus callosum or its failure to ever appear in a brain.
There was one famous person born without a corpus callosum. Was he famous for his defective cognitive abilities? No, quite the opposite. The man was Kim Peek, whose corpus callosum never appeared. Peek was famous for his astonishing cognitive abilities. It has been widely stated that Kim Peek could recall the contents of all of 7000 books that he had read. He also had the skill of calendar calculation, the ability to quickly name the day of the week over a huge time period of many decades, given only a date such as October 22, 1921 or April 3, 1908. Peek could also read at blazing speeds.
The paper "A Review of the Savant Syndrome and its Possible Relationship to Epilepsy" by neurologist John R. Hughes has some astonishing accounts of extraordinary mental abilities. He states this about Kim Peek:
"Kim reads the left side of a page with his left eye and simultaneously the right side of the page with his right eye (without a corpus callosum). The time taken for these two pages for Kim is usually 8 seconds and upon testing for retention he was 99% correct of the material just read [2]. These values are in contrast to 45 seconds for reading and 45% correct on testing seen in a group of normal individuals."
Daniel Treffert MD had this to say about Kim Peek, one of many autistic savants Treffert spent years studying:
"In spite of extensive central nervous system (CNS) damage from the time of birth, including an encephalocele and absent corpus callosum, Kim had one of the most extraordinary
brain capacities I have ever encountered. Kim had memorized—yes,
memorized—literally thousands of books....
Kim Peek was, and remains, the Mount Everest of memory. Other accounts have told of some other 'memory giants' in the past. I am familiar with all of them, but none can match Kim’s factual memory— so deep and seemingly without limit—and I doubt any in the future will rival that astounding capacity either. Kim’s data bank of 15 areas of expertise—history, geography, space exploration, the Bible, sports, area codes, ZIP codes, maps, to name only a few—will remain, I am convinced, unsurpassed. Moreover, unlike so many memory giants of the past whose memories were without reckoning,' in recent years Kim had become a living Google™, linking all those facts with astonishing rapidity and in ways that sometimes took me a day or 2 to find out what the connection was."
Kim Peek and other cases of high mental function (and sometimes way above average mental function) despite loss of the corpus callosum (causing drastically reduced brain flows) help to demolish the claim of neuroscientist Michael W. Cole that brain flows are the main source of the human mind.
Postscript: The simple wonder of the ability of humans to quickly give correct answers when asked questions about material learned long ago is a wonder impossible to explain under any theory that brains store memories. Humans make things that allow instant retrieval of information, and we know the type of things that allow such instant retrieval. They are: addresses, indexes and sorting. The brain has no addresses and no indexes; and the physical structure of the brain makes sorting impossible within a brain.
Today I went to youtube.com, and tried for the first time an online quiz about World War II, one with 15 "easy" questions, 20 questions of medium difficulty, and 15 "hard" questions. You have to answer quickly, with only about 6 seconds allowed for each question. I quickly recalled the correct answers to 49 out of 50 questions, missing only the question about the Tuskegee airmen. I had not at all crammed for this exam. Since the time I started blogging in 2013, I have been writing entirely about topics other than World War II, and I haven't read a history of World War II in many years. But I did read many books about World War II many years ago; and that was apparently sufficient for me to score 49 out of 50. How could this happen if memories are stored in synapses, which we know are built of proteins with an average lifetime of only a few weeks? It couldn't. No one has a credible theory of how anyone could instantly answer any uncommon question using a brain. The only credible belief about memory is that memory is a metaphysical, spiritual, psychical or "mysterious energy" phenomenon, rather than a brain phenomenon.