Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Scanning Them Like Crazy: the Stanford Digital Brain Project

In 2013 the European Union launched a 2.7 billion dollar Human Brain Project. Its incredibly ambitious goal was to create a super-computer model of the human brain. The EU's Human Brain Project announced goals of proving conventional dogmas about the brain. At the page here we read that "the HBP is conducting a coordinated series of experiments to identify the neuronal mechanisms behind episodic memory, and validate them by computational models and robotic systems."  This is an assertion of the unproven dogma that episodic memory can be explained by brain processes; and it is a goofy statement, given how silly it is to think that such a dogma could be validated by doing computer models or research into robots. 

Ten years later, the Human Brain Project concluded, and issued a document giving a summary of what it had accomplished. It released a statement here summarizing what it accomplished in its ten years of heavy funding, a statement entitled "The Human Brain Project ends: What has been achieved." We read the following statements that fail to mention any notable discoveries about the brain:

  • "The HBP has produced more than 3000 academic publications and more than 160 digital tools, medical and technological applications, an open research infrastructure – EBRAINS – as well as a multinational and uniquely interdisciplinary community that would not have come together otherwise."
  • "The HBP has driven outstanding advances in brain research and in the development of medicine and technology applications. Among the research highlights accomplished by the HBP are the world-leading 3D atlases of the brain, breakthroughs in personalised brain medicine, and the development of new brain-inspired technologies, e.g., in artificial intelligence and neuromorphic computing.". 
  • "The HBP has built a digital platform that fosters large-scale collaborations. The EBRAINS digital research infrastructure offers access to digital tools, models, data and services, facilitating the integration of brain science across disciplines and national borders."
There seems to be no mention in the wrap-up document of any specific discovery that was made about the brain from all this research. The document does not claim that anything was done to back up the main claims neuroscientists make about brains, such as the claims that brains are the source of the human and the storage place of memories. 

Billions had been spent on the fool's errand of trying to understand minds by building computer programs simulating the brain, things called "brain foundation models." We now have a similar project involving "brain foundation models": a project called the  Stanford Digital Brain Project. It has an undisclosed amount of funding from three wealthy philanthropists. 

The plan will be to have about 100 subjects undergo many hours of scanning with a highest-intensity 7-Tesla MRI scanner, while the subjects are undergoing various mental tasks. Subjects will also do cognitive activities while they are wearing some fancy head device called an OPM-MEG system. That is a device that can be called a "brain magnetism sniffer." Magnetic traces coming from the brain are so very weak (and so confounded by other magnetic traces) that the device seems like a joke from the standpoint of detecting brain activity in a way that will shed light on the origin of minds and memory. 

I have not researched whether there are medical risks from using an OPM-MEG on your head. I do know of very substantial risks that may come from the level of 7-Tesla brain scanning that will be going on in the Stanford Digital Brain Project.

An article on the project states this:

"The team behind the project intends to train the artificial-intelligence (AI)-based model, also known as a foundation model, on about 14,000 hours of imaging data that they aim to collect from roughly 100 people over the next five years." 

14,000 hours of 7-Tesla (7T) brain scanning would amount to roughly 140 hours of brain scanning per subject. Such scanning would cause very substantial risks of health damage to such subjects. Almost all previous use of MRI brain scanners has been the use of 1.5 Tesla (1.5T scanners) and 3-Tesla (3T) scanners that involve much less exposure to magnetism and electromagnetic fields than a 7T scanner. Even with the much weaker 3T scanners, very substantial risks have been identified. 

One danger of fMRI scans is well-known: the risk of the very strong magnets used by such machines causing some metal object to be hurled at a high speed, causing injury or death.  In 2001 a six-year-old boy was killed in the US during an fMRI scan, when the machine turned an oxygen canister into a flying projectile.  There is always a risk of lingering psychological trauma when certain people are put in some noisy high-tech machine and told they must be silent and not move for a long time such as an hour. There is also the risk that the more powerful fMRI scans (and longer fMRI scans) may raise the risk of cancer in the person getting getting the scan.

The 2009 study here ("Genotoxic effects of 3 T magnetic resonance imaging in cultured human lymphocytes") cautions about the use of a high-intensity ("3T and above") fMRI, and states that "potential health risks are implied in the MRI and especially HF MRI environment due to high-static magnetic fields, fast gradient magnetic fields, and strong radiofrequency electromagnetic fields," also noting that "these results suggest that exposure to 3 T MRI induces  genotoxic effects in human  lymphocytes," referring to effects  that may cause cancer. 

There are very few studies comparing cancer rates in those who have had fMRI scans and those who have not had such scans. Now neuroscientists are starting to do neuroscience experiments on humans with more powerful fMRI scanners such as 7T scanners, which have potentially higher risks.  So claims by scientists that "fMRI scans are safe" are not candid about risks. It is entirely possible that every time someone has a long fMRI scan (as often done for neuroscience research) that he is increasing his lifetime risk of getting cancer. 

Claims that "fMRI scans are safe" are typically claims made based on short scans (such as a few minutes) with 1.5T and 3T scanners, not claims based on hour-long scans often done in neuroscience research,  not claims based on scans with the higher-intensity 7T scanners, and certainly not at all claims based on more than a hundred hours of 7T scanning on a single subject (something that has almost never occurred).  

A paper tells us the following about the 3T MRI machines that have been replacing the older 1.5T MRI machines, suggesting their magnetic fields are much stronger than the strength needed to lift a car:

"The main magnetic field of a 3T system is 60,000 times
 the earth's magnet field. The strength of electromagnets
 used to pick up cars in junk yards is about the field strength 
of MRI systems with field strengths from 1.5-2.0T.
 It is strong enough to pull fork-lift tires off of machinery,
 pull heavy-duty floor buffers and mop buckets into
 the bore of the magnet, pull stretchers across the room
 and turn oxygen bottles into flying projectiles reaching
 speeds in excess of 40 miles per hour."   

According to the paper here ("The effects of repeated brain MRI on
chromosomal damage") which 
judged genetic damage from 3T MRI scans, "While we do not report any change after a single MRI session, repeated exposure was associated with an increase in the frequency of chromosomal deletions." The paper "Genotoxic effects of 3 T magnetic resonance imaging in cultured human lymphocytes" found that chromosomal aberrations (CA) increased in proportion to the length of time someone had a 3T MRI scan. It says, "the frequencies of CAs in lymphocytes exposed for 0, 45, 67, and 89 min were 1.33, 2.33, 3.67, and 4.67 per 200 cells, respectively." Such chromosomal deletions and aberrations probably increase cancer risk, or the risk of equally devastating problems.

Scientists do not track the long-term health of subjects they have subjected to long fMRI scans. Their rule is "scan them and forget them." It often happens that things that were once not thought to be carcinogenic are later shown to be carcinogenic. For example, I read that the US surgeon general is saying alcohol use causes 20,000 deaths a year in the US. In the high school I attended students were forced to dissect cats, and the dead cats were stored in a vat of formaldehyde, which often got on the students' skin. We now know formaldehyde is a carcinogen. 

When we examine the history of fMRI scans, we see a history of overconfidence, and authorities dogmatically asserting that "fMRI scans are perfectly safe," when they did not actually know whether they were perfectly safe.  Not many years ago there arose the great "contrast agent" scandal.  Scientists began to learn that what are called "contrast agent" fMRI scans may not be so safe. In such "contrast agent" scans, a subject is given an injection that increases the visual contrast of the fMRI scan.  For a long time, the main substance in such an injection was gadolinium.  A mainstream cancer web site states, "Tissue and autopsy reports have also confirmed that gadolinium can accumulate in the brain and other organs." The results can be a health disaster, as described here. A 2019 Science Daily story says, "New contrast agent could make MRIs safer," letting us know that many of them previously were not so safe. On the same Science Daily web site, we read a 2017 news story with the title "MRI contrast agents accumulate in the brain."  A 2020 paper ("Side Effect of Gadolinium MRI Contrast Agents") says this:

"Until recently, it was believed that gadolinium is effectively cleared within 24 hours after intravenous injection, and that it does not have any harmful effects on the human body. However, recent studies on animals and analyses of clinical data have indicated that gadolinium is retained in the body for many years post-administration, and may cause various diseases."

Neuroscientists extensively used such contrast agents (as described here), very often putting human subjects at risk. typically for the sake of junk poorly designed studies falling far short of the best experimental practices. You can do a Google search for "gadolinium deposition" to learn more about this issue. 

What will be the risks for these 100 subjects who will undergo roughly 100 hours of 7T brain scanning for the Stanford Digital Brain Project, enduring a level of MRI exposure that few if anyone has ever undergone? Based on what I cite above, we can presume that there will be very substantial risks involving an increase in the risk of such subjects getting cancer. The Stanford Digital Brain Project therefore seems like an immoral gamble with the health of its volunteers. 

I queried Google, asking "What studies have been done on the safety of long scanning in 7T MRI scanners?" I got an "AI overview" that included the following: "Large-scale multi-center and subject-tolerance studies (such as those by Hansson et al., 2020 and Theysohn et al., 2014) show that roughly 20% of subjects experience moderate vertigo and up to 38% experience mild vertigo or dizziness during table movement, caused by magnetohydrodynamic effects on the inner ear's vestibular system." When I looked up those references, I found that one states that up to 10% of subjects reported headaches after brain scanning. We can only imagine what kind of cancer risk is being incurred from brain scanning that produces headaches and "magnetohydrodynamic effects on the inner ear's vestibular system." 

 A year 2024 study ("Evaluation of the Biological Effects of Exposures to Magnetic Resonance Imaging on Single-Strand DNA: An In-vivo Study") found that MRI scanners only half as powerful as 3T scanners (and only 21% as powerful as 7T MRI scanners) can produce DNA-damaging genotoxic effects.  It reported this:

"The DNA single-strand breaks were significant for all tested parameters in both MRI 1.5 T (p<0.01) and 3.0 T (p<0.001)....The percentage of cells destroyed in the group exposed to 3.0 T MRI was increased to 12.65 ± 1.0 after 10 minutes of exposure."

As shown in its Table 1, the study found that with a 3.0T MRI scanner, the longer you scan, the more DNA damage is done. The reported damage after 40 minutes of 3.0T MRI scanning is given a numerical value of 57, which is nearly twice as high as the damage done after only 10 minutes of scanning (damage given a numerical rating of 32). A similar relation is reported in Table 4, using a different measure of damage.  Using that measure, 10 minutes of 3.0T MRI produces DNA damage given a numerical value of 12.66, but 40  minutes of 3.0T MRI produces almost twice-as-bad DNA damage given a numerical value of 22.38.  Any DNA damage tends to increase cancer risk. 

MRI cancer risks

The 2022 paper here ("The effects of repeated brain MRI on
chromosomal damage") reports, "The total number of damaged cells increased by 3.2% (95% CI 1.5–4.8%) per MRI (Fig. 2d–h) (p < 0.001); this increase being higher during the first ten MRI sessions than during the last ten ones (p for interaction = 0.016)." Get the picture? The more MRI scans, the higher your risk of damage that may increase your cancer risk. 

The 2025 paper "A scoping review and evidence map of radiofrequency field exposure and genotoxicity: assessing in vivo, in vitro, and epidemiological data" is a paper that mentions MRI only once. But it is a paper about the risks of "radiofrequency electromagnetic field (RF-EMF) exposure," and that includes MRI. Ask Google "is MRI an RF-EMF device?" and you will get an answer of "yes, a Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) machine uses a radiofrequency (RF) electromagnetic field as one of its core components." The paper refers to "500 pertinent studies" and noted that "DNA base damage studies showed the highest proportion of effects." The paper says that "genotoxicity findings for different cell types revealed varying sensitivities to RF exposure" and that "normal brain cells were found to be very sensitive (76% of 54 studies)."  

The paper noted that "a complex relationship was identified between exposure intensity and duration, with duration emerging as a critical determinant of outcomes." That is to be expected. The longer someone is scanned in an MRI and the more intense the magnetic intensity, the greater the risk. Scanning someone for a few minutes in a 1.5T MRI or a 3T MRI may have very little risk; but scanning someone for 100 hours in a 7T scanner will have very grave risks. 

The Transmitter article mentions that in previous projects trying to create "brain foundation models" relied on scanning only about 1 hour per person. It states this: "Other foundational models have been trained on existing datasets: BrainLM and Brain-JEPA drew on thousands of hours of primarily resting-state fMRI data from tens of thousands of people, and Meta’s TRIBE v2 mined more than 1,000 hours of fMRI data from 720 people watching movies, listening to podcasts and reading." So what's with the reckless cancer-gambling of the Stanford Digital Brain Project subjecting 100 subjects to something like 70 or 100 or 140 hours each of highest-intensity 7T brain scanning? What kind of Russian roulette will be played here with the health of these test subjects? 

One of those links in the quote above goes to the paper here, with a Table 1 describing eight different fMRI data-gathering projects, 7 of them using only 3T MRI scanners (and averaging only about 2 hours of scanning per subject), and only one of them using a 7T MRI scanner (and using only about 1 hour of scanning per subject).  

Nothing will be learned from such a project clarifying the source of the human mind and how human memory can occur. fMRI studies merely measure blood flow in the brain, rather than actually measuring electrical activity.  Endless fMRI studies have already been done on people engaging in cognitive activities. Such studies fail to show any decent sign of brains producing thinking or learning or recall. What typically happens is that you will merely get some tiny 1 part in 200 fluctuation that shows up somewhere in a brain (tiny parts of the brain that differ from one subject to the next, and one experiment to the next). Not being highly reproducible effects, such fluctuations can easily be explained as mere random variations. 

The idea that you can create some computer model that will clarify minds and memory is nonsense. Computers are not brains, brains are not like computers, and brains are neither the source of minds nor the storage place of human memories. The microscopic examination of brain tissue has never revealed the slightest trace of anything a human has learned. Trying to figure out the human mind by creating a computer model based on brain scans is a fool's errand. 

If any computer system or computer software setup is ever called a "digital brain," that will be misrepresentation. Brains do not have the characteristics of today's digital computers. Computers have operating systems and software, and reliably transmit information everywhere. Brains have no operating system and no software, and the synapses that make up so much of brains do not even reliably transmit information (with each chemical synapse transmitting an action potential with a reliability of only 50% or less).  Computers have various types of addressing systems that help explain their instant retrieval of relevant information. Brains have no addressing system. 

A Stanford University article on the  Stanford Digital Brain Project gives us a revealing neuroscientist quote about the project. A neuroscientist says, "Imagine being able to test a new circuit intervention for depression by simulating its effects on a digital brain model before ever trying it in a patient." Does this person actually think that you can test a treatment for depression by trying it on a computer, and seeing whether the treatment makes the computer feel happier?

goofy neuroscientist
Magnetism Mania

Friday, November 13, 2026

No, Brain Flows Do Not Compose the Mind

 When writing up some scientific paper that may involve either experimental research or theorizing, a scientist often may think to himself questions such as "Is there some way to frame this work so that it sounds like important work worthy of publication?" or "Is there some way to spin this work so that it sounds like important work worthy of being cited, so that my citation count will increase?" But a scientist willing to "think big" may be more ambitious, and ask himself: "Is there some way to spin this work so that it sounds like something I could parlay into a book deal?" 

There are two main types of scientists who try to parlay their work into book deals: the "grand theory" scientist and the experimental research scientist.  The "grand theory" scientist is often someone thinking: how can I make my theory into a best-selling book? 

scientist interested in book deal

The "grand theory" scientist trying to become a best-selling author is someone we cannot trust to accurately summarize facts and accurately report on reality, because he is so very badly biased. Such a scientist tends to report everything in a way that tries to make his grand theory seem credible. 

We might call neuroscientist Michael W. Cole one of these "grand theory" scientists, except that there's nothing very grand at all about the theory he has recently been hawking while promoting his recent book. It is the theory that the human mind is explained by "brain flows." There's nothing very new or exciting here. Cole is the author of a recent book entitled "Brain Flows: How Network Dynamics Compose the Human Mind." 

Cole has a blog site entitled "Neural Flows" devoted to pitching the erroneous idea that brain flows explain the human mind. Here are some recent posts at that site:
  • "Emotions as global low-dimensional brain flow patterns": this is a vacuous post making no substantive argument and making no reference to any neuroscience studies. We have ridiculous-sounding jargon-stuffed gobbledygook such as "I posit that emotions are global low-dimensional information-framing brain flow attractors."
  • "Fluidized brain flows and the dynamics of consciousness": We read, "The thought I had while watching that video is that fluidized sand is an excellent model of brain flow dynamics...Like sand, the brain is composed of many physically separate objects (cells) that interact physically (via synapses and electric fields)." This sounds nonsensical, because cells are enormously organized components (unlike grains of sand that are simple particles), and no electricity passes between grains of sand in a flow of sand. We read, "My idea was that the primary purpose of the brain’s pervasive spontaneous activity may be to keep the brain in a fluidized state." The brain is not in a fluidized state. Like trees locked into place by their roots, the neurons in the brain are locked into place by all the dendrites and synapses that neurons are entangled with. We read the claim that "a series of studies have found that there is more spontaneous activity throughout human (and other animal) brains during consciousness than during a variety of non-conscious states." To the contrary, as discussed here, neurons fire just as much during sleep as they do when people are awake; and that is one of many very many reasons for thinking that the brain is not the source of the human mind. The comparison in this post between sand flow and brains flows is laughable. 
  • "What’s generative about generative network neuroscience." We have this boast: "In a 2024 study, my lab used activity flow modeling to show that distributed flows from other brain areas were causally sufficient to generate face selectivity in the fusiform face area." The reference is to an unimpressive paper that merely does a whole bunch of arbitrary analytics on some brain scanning data gathered by others, some analysis so convoluted that we seem to end up with no robust evidence for anything. Claims about "face selectivity in the fusiform face area" are not well-justified, as I discuss here. 
  • "Generative network neuroscience." This is a post making this dull-sounding boast: "We found that, indeed, resting-state functional connections are equivalent in some fundamental ways to model connectivity weights." 
  • "Enhancing scientific inference with evidence quality maps." Cole suggests making scientific graphs with nodes and links (something already done) and then grandly boasts, "I expect – like Tim Berners-Lee’s 1989 [World-Wide] Web proposal – that the ideas shared here will have an impact well beyond scientific practices." 
There's nothing in these posts that substantiates his claim that "network dynamics compose the human mind." An excerpt from the book also fails to substantiate the claim. He complains that it's  "like we’ve been doing neuroscience research with our hands tied behind our backs" because people haven't been concentrating on "brain flows" the way he has. He incorrectly states that "abstract task rule representations, such as 'if both items are the same,'  have been identified within prefrontal cortex (and elsewhere). " No such representations have been discovered, and claims of such discoveries are examples of "Jesus in my toast" pareidolia. Unjustified claims about finding "representations" in brains are an epidemic in today's neuroscience literature. Cole incorrectly states, "This brain region is termed the fusiform face area, and it is more active when a participant sees a face relative to seeing other visual categories (such as a house or tool)," linking to the low-quality paper here (using a way-too-small study group size). 

Then there's a long interview with Cole, in which he seems to ramble on and on and wander around in the woods, without ever giving us a compelling-sounding quote. We do not seem to get any quote from Cole backing up in any substantive way the claim that "network dynamics compose the human mind."

There's a good way to test the idea that "brain flows" explain human cognition. We can consider the question: what type of condition or operation produces the greatest change in brain flows, and what is the effect of such a condition or operation? If brain flows explain human cognition, we would expect that such a condition or operation would have the most enormous negative effect on human cognition. 

The type of condition that most affects the flow of electricity in the brain is the loss of the corpus callosum. The corpus callosum is a bundle of fibers that connect the left hemisphere of the brain and the right hemisphere of the brain. 

brain hemispheres


There are two ways in which such a condition can arise. The first way is if the corpus callosum fails to ever form during development. That is called agenesis of the corpus callosum. People lacking a corpus callosum have basically two separate brains inside their skull. Does this result in two minds, as we would expect under the theory that the brain makes the mind? No, people lacking a corpus callosum have a single, unified mind.  

Agnesis means a failure of something in a developing child during a mother's pregnancy. The paper here is entitled "Outcomes Associated With Isolated Agenesis of the Corpus Callosum: A Meta-analysis." The paper distinguishes between what it calls "cACC" and "pACC," defining cACC as complete agenesis of the corpus callosum (in other words, the total failure of the corpus callosum to appear) and defining pACC as partial aegnesis of the corpus callosum (partial  failure of the corpus callosum to appear). The paper gives us these statistics, telling us that in only a relatively small minority of cases of a complete congenital absence of the corpus callosum are there cognitive problems:

"In cACC, chromosomal anomalies occurred in 4.81% (95% confidence interval [CI], 2.2–8.4) of the cases. Gross and fine motor control were abnormal in 4.40% (95% CI, 0.6–11.3) and 10.98% (95% CI, 4.1–20.6) of the cases, respectively, whereas 6.80% (95% CI, 1.7–14.9) presented with epilepsy. Abnormal cognitive status occurred in 15.16% (95% CI, 6.9–25.9) of cases. In partial ACC, the rate of chromosomal anomalies was 7.45% (95% CI, 2.0–15.9). Fine motor control was affected in 11.74% (95% CI, 0.9–32.1) of the cases, and 16.11% (95% CI, 2.5–38.2) presented with epilepsy. Cognitive status was affected in 17.25% (95% CI, 3.0–39.7) of cases."

So in only about 16% of the subjects with a complete lack of a corpus callosum was there an abnormal cognitive status. These cACC (complete agenesis of the corpus callosum) people were basically people with two separate brains in their skulls. But most of them apparently had normal unified minds, since the paper says that only 15% of them had an abnormal cognitive status. 

Below is a quote from a book written by a medical doctor:

"Case I. — Dr. Alexander Bruce reports a man of ordinary intelligence and good character, and who, for thirteen years, did the work of a porter with perfect satisfaction, and exhibited no notable peculiarities. Yet in this man the corpus callosum was completely absent (23).
Case II. — Malinverni reports a soldier, aged 30 years, of ordinary intelligence, but with a slight tendency to melancholia, who had complete absence of the corpus callosum (24).
Case III. — Eichler reports a laborer, 43 years of age, married, diligent and capable, a good husband, sober and quiet, and could read and write, yet he had no corpus callosum, and had other important malformations of the brain (25)."

We have three cases of people with no corpus callosum, meaning that they had two separated hemispheres of the brain. But in each case their mind seemed normal. 

Sometimes to prevent seizures, the entire corpus callosum is surgically severed. This is sometimes called a split brain operation. The operation leaves patients with a single unified self. Insinuations to the contrary sometimes made by materialists are an example of severe deception. 

Physician Michael Egnor states the following about Sperry's research:

"The neuroscientist Roger Sperry studied scores of split-brain patients. He found, surprisingly, that in ordinary life the patients showed little effect. Each patient was still one person. The intellect and will – the capacity to have abstract thought and to choose – remained unified. Only by meticulous testing could Sperry find any differences: their perceptions were altered by the surgery. Sensations – elicited by touch or vision – could be presented to one hemisphere of the brain, and not be experienced in the other hemisphere. Speech production is associated with the left hemisphere of the brain; patients could not name an object presented to the right hemisphere (via the left visual field). Yet they could point to the object with their left hand (which is controlled by the right hemisphere). The most remarkable result of Sperry’s Nobel Prize­–winning work was that the person’s intellect and will – what we might call the soul – remained undivided. The brain can be cut in half, but the intellect and will cannot. The intellect and will are metaphysically simple."

The actual facts about split-brain surgery are related here by a surgeon who has performed such an operation. He states this about split-brain patients:

"After the surgery they are unaffected in everyday life, except for the diminished seizures. They are one person after the surgery, as they were before."

The surgeon states: "In a rational scientific community in which evidence and reason held sway, split-brain surgery would be hailed as compelling evidence for dualism and the immateriality of the intellect and will." One thing is for sure: the cases we have for loss of the corpus callosum and preservation of mental function are cases that very much discredit Michael W. Cole's claim that "brain flows" explain human minds. It seems that human minds work just fine when brain flows are greatly reduced, by the loss of the corpus callosum or its failure to ever appear in a brain. 

There was one famous person born without a corpus callosum. Was he famous for his defective cognitive abilities? No, quite the opposite. The man was Kim Peek, whose corpus callosum never appeared.  Peek was famous for his astonishing cognitive abilities.  It has been widely stated that Kim Peek could recall the contents of all of 7000 books that he had read. He also had the skill of calendar calculation, the ability to quickly name the day of the week over a huge time period of many decades, given only a date such as October 22, 1921 or April 3, 1908. Peek could also read at blazing speeds.

The paper "A Review of the Savant Syndrome and its Possible Relationship to Epilepsy" by neurologist John R. Hughes has some astonishing accounts of extraordinary mental abilities. He states this about Kim Peek:

"Kim reads the left side of a page with his left eye and simultaneously the right side of the page with his right eye (without a corpus callosum). The time taken for these two pages for Kim is usually 8 seconds and upon testing for retention he was 99% correct of the material just read [2]. These values are in contrast to 45 seconds for reading and 45% correct on testing seen in a group of normal individuals."

Daniel Treffert MD had this to say about Kim Peek, one of many autistic savants Treffert spent years studying:

"In spite of extensive central nervous system (CNS) damage from the time of birth, including an encephalocele and absent corpus callosum, Kim had one of the most extraordinary
brain capacities I have ever encountered. Kim had memorized—yes,
memorized—literally thousands of books.... 
Kim Peek was, and remains, the Mount Everest of memory. Other accounts have told of some other 'memory giants' in the past. I am familiar with all of them, but none can match Kim’s factual memory— so deep and seemingly without limit—and I doubt any in the future will rival that astounding capacity either. Kim’s data bank of 15 areas of expertise—history, geography, space exploration, the Bible, sports, area codes, ZIP codes, maps, to name only a few—will remain, I am convinced, unsurpassed. Moreover, unlike so many memory giants of the past whose memories were without reckoning,' in recent years Kim had become a living Google™, linking all those facts with astonishing rapidity and in ways that sometimes took me a day or 2 to find out what the connection was."

Kim Peek and other cases of high mental function (and sometimes way above average mental function) despite loss of the corpus callosum (causing drastically reduced brain flows) help to demolish the claim of neuroscientist Michael W. Cole that brain flows are the main source of the human mind. 

Postscript: The simple wonder of the ability of humans to quickly give correct answers when asked questions about material learned long ago is a wonder impossible to explain under any theory that brains store memories. Humans make things that allow instant retrieval of information, and we know the type of things that allow such instant retrieval. They are: addresses, indexes and sorting. The brain has no addresses and no indexes; and the physical structure of the brain makes sorting impossible within a brain. 

Today I went to youtube.com, and tried for the first time an online quiz about World War II, one with 15 "easy" questions, 20 questions of medium difficulty, and 15 "hard" questions. You have to answer quickly, with only about 6 seconds allowed for each question. I quickly recalled the correct answers to 49 out of 50 questions, missing only the question about the Tuskegee airmen. I had not at all crammed for this exam. Since the time I started blogging in 2013, I have been writing entirely about topics other than World War II, and I haven't read a history of World War II in many years. But I did read many books about World War II many years ago; and that was apparently sufficient for me to score 49 out of 50.  How could this happen if memories are stored in synapses, which we know are built of proteins with an average lifetime of only a few weeks? It couldn't. No one has a credible theory of how anyone could instantly answer any uncommon question using a brain. The only credible belief about memory is that memory is a metaphysical, spiritual, psychical or "mysterious energy" phenomenon, rather than a brain phenomenon.

Monday, November 9, 2026

"There's a Genome Recipe for Brains" Is As False as "Brains Make Minds"

 About 1950 the DNA molecule was discovered inside chromosomes,  scientists began making an untrue claim about DNA, the claim that it specified how to make an organism. There were various ways in which this false idea was stated, all equally false:

  • Many described DNA or the genome as a blueprint for an organism.
  • Many said DNA or the genome is a recipe for making an organism.
  • Many said DNA or the genome is a program for building an organism, making an analogy to a computer program.
  • Many claimed that DNA or genomes specify the anatomy of an organism. 
  • Many claimed that genotypes (the DNA in organisms) specify phenotypes (the observable characteristics of an organism).
  • Many claimed that genotypes (the DNA in organisms) "map"  phenotypes (the observable characteristics of an organism) or "map to" phenotypes.
  • Many claimed that DNA contains "all the instructions needed to make an organism."
  • Many claimed that there is a "genetic architecture" for an organism's body or some fraction of that body. 
  • Many claimed that DNA or its genes "guide," "direct" or "control" the nine-month process by which a zygote progresses to become a full-sized human baby. 
  • Using a little equation,  many claimed that a "genotype plus the environment equals the phenotype," a formulation as false  as the preceding statements, since we know of nothing in the environment that would cause phenotypes to arise from genotypes that do not specify such phenotypes. 
There was never any justification for making any such claims. The only coding system that has ever been discovered in DNA is a system allowing only low-level chemical information to be specified.  That coding system is known as the genetic code, and it is merely a system whereby certain combinations of nucleotides in DNA stand for amino acids.  So a section of DNA can specify the amino acids that make up a protein molecule. But no one has ever discovered any coding system by which DNA could specify anything larger than a protein molecule. Below is the genetic code, the only coding system ever discovered in DNA or its genes. The chemicals listed on the outer ring are types of amino acids. The A, T, C and G are types of nucleotides in a gene ( adenine, thymine, cytosine and guanine).

The genetic code

A billion-dollar project was executed in the 1990's to completely map the human genome. Geneticists kept telling us that the project would reveal in DNA and its genes instructions for how to build a body. The project was completed around 2001. No instructions for building a body or any of its organs or cells or any of the organelle components of cells was ever found in DNA. 

Did our scientists then "fess up" and confess how they had been misleading us? Some of them started to tell the truth, but very many of them just stuck to their old lies about DNA being a body specification.  See the appendix of this post for a long list of scientists and doctors who told us the truth on this matter -- that DNA is not any kind of blueprint or recipe or program for making a human body. 

We see here a shocking case of a major group of scientists simply refusing to accept what nature was telling them -- that a human body does not arise from a reading of a specification in DNA or its genes telling how to build a human body. 

The latest example of a scientist continuing to teach the same old groundless falsehoods about DNA and its genes is the article "The genome offers a recipe, not a blueprint, for the brain" by neuroscientist Ila Fiete. Fiete tries to advance the old "recipe" version of the false claim that DNA is a specification for making a human body. 

When such a claim is made, a person will talk about "ingredients" being added. Whenever a person talks that way, he will sound like a biology ignoramus. Ingredients are simple things. The organs in human bodies are not built from simple things, but enormously organized components, components way, way too organized to be sensibly described as "ingredients."  Organ systems are built from organs and other very complex components; organs are built from tissues; tissues are built from cells so organized they are often compared to cities or factories; cells are built from many thousands of very complex and well-arranged organelles of many types; organelles are built from thousands of types of proteins and also protein complexes so complex they are often called "molecular machines"; protein complexes are built from very many types of protein molecules that each require special arrangements of hundreds or thousands of amino acids. None of these layers of organization larger than a protein molecule is specified by DNA or its genes. 

The diagram below specifies levels of organization in the human body. The black bar tells some of these levels that are not specified by a genome, not specified by DNA or its genes. 

what DNA does not specify


Fiete makes this "starts out fairly true, but ends up false" statement: "Genes specify ingredients and a short list of directions, outlining which things to combine, in what quantity and when." No, genes do not specify "which things to combine, in what quantity and when," if you are talking about any level of complexity higher than a protein molecule. DNA and its genes (the genome) do not have any information about any "when." Fiete follow this statement with a true sentence and a groundless hand-waving sentence not matching anything that scientists have discovered. Referring to genes, she says:

"They don’t specify the border between the secondary visual cortex and its neighbor, or the wiring between each pair of neurons, or the precise size of the cortical sheet in each individual’s brain. Instead, these quantities emerge through the playing out of simpler processes that can lead to the self-organization of complex structures."

The reference to emergence and self-organization is just empty hand-waving. When scientists lack any explanation for how something in the body arises, they may refer to "emergence" or "self-organization," and when we hear such terms we should always be regarding such terms as indications that the person speaking has no substantial explanation. 

Fiete refers to "developmental biologist Lewis Wolpert’s 'French flag' model, in which a molecular gradient specifies locations in a tissue, activating downstream genes at specific concentration thresholds to determine what structure forms there."  There was never any good evidence to support this claim, and late in his career Wolpert confessed the lack of good evidence for it.  In 2015 he was asked this: "Where do you think the French Flag model fits with our current understanding of positional information, and what do you think are the exciting questions at the moment?" He answered this:

"There are problems we haven’t solved. It is terrible, but we still don’t have a molecular basis for it. If I still had an active lab, finding the molecular basis for positional information would be my objective, but would be quite tricky, since I’m not a biochemist or molecular biologist. There is one case of a molecule that might encode positional information, Prod 1, which is graded along the amphibian limb and was discovered by Jeremy Brockes. But it would be nice to find similar molecules in other systems."

This was the most damning confession. By saying "we still don't have a molecular basis for it," Lewis Wolpert pretty much confessed here that the "positional information" claim that he had encouraged innumerable times in his career was basically baloney or BS. He confessed that there was merely "one case of a molecule that might encode positional information," in one type of organism, making it sound like there was no general basis for thinking that molecules specify the positions that cells should go to.  The claim associated with Wolpert that "morphogen gradients" tell cells where to go is debunked in my post here. 

Trying to create an impression or suspicion in the reader's mind that genes specify the position of cells, Fiete states, "Thomas Gregor and his colleagues report that multiple gap genes together specify a cell’s position through lateral interactions better than a single gradient without interactions." The claim is untrue, and genes do not and cannot possibly specify the position of any cell. In the study referred to, a mere claim was made that "expression levels of the four gap genes can be jointly decoded into an optimal specification of position with 1% accuracy." The expression level of a gene is how often the gene is used at particular times and places, and is something very different from what information is inside a gene and what a gene specifies. Gene expression levels are something figured out by scientists using high-tech equipment. A gene does not have any information on its expression level, just as a word does not have any information on how often it is used or quoted. 

What was going on in the paper was something similar to analyzing how often a word is used in a book, to predict which paragraph or chapter in a book the word was found. Just as doing such analysis does nothing to show that a word specifies the structure of a paragraph, analyzing gene expression levels and correlating them with some cell positions does nothing to show that genes specify the positions of cells.  The paper authors confess that their analysis "contrasts with the traditional interpretation of the gap genes as forming 'expression domains' that are either on or off," sounding like they were doing some contrarian analysis conflicting with previous studies.  Their claims involve one brief stage in the development of only one species, a type of fly. No one has ever shown that in general genes specify the positions of cells in species. 

Below is a Google Gemini infographic explaining gene expression. We see how a small section of a gene (containing different combinations of the nucleotide chemicals adenine, thymine, cytosine and guanine) specify a particular section of a protein (consisting of some amino acids).  There is no coding system by which any combinations of these chemicals in a gene (adenine, thymine, cytosine and guanine) can represent anything other than an amino acid or a "stop" signal meaning the end of an amino acid sequence. Genes only specify low-level chemical things, not higher-level biology things such as how to build a cell or any of the organelles that make up a cell, or where to place a cell or where to place any of the proteins in a cell. 

gene expression

In the following quote Fiete gives us a hint that the "genome as brain recipe" in her title is not actually true. She states this: "My colleague P. Robin Hiesinger notes that even the cake analogy may give genes too much credit; typical recipes specify ingredients, as well as the order and duration of steps, but in development, these can themselves be emergent, as seen in the assembly of the sorting plate that guides fly eye neurons into the brain." Genes do not specify where and when their corresponding proteins should be used. 

Brains are made mainly of neurons, and genes do not specify how to make any neuron or any of the organelles from which neurons are constructed. So the genome is not a recipe for building a brain, and is not a recipe of the neurons or synapses or axons that make up a brain. 

After saying nothing of any substance to back up her claim that the genome is a recipe for building brains, and nothing of any substance to back up her hand-waving claims of "self-organization," Fiete has a paragraph lecturing us about the type of scientists we need. On that topic I say: what we need are neuroscientists who do not tell us old wives' tales about DNA and genes, scientists who talk straight to us about the physical limitations of genomes and the physical limitations of brains. Straight talk about the physical limitations of genomes and their contents leads to the conclusion that genes cannot be any program, blueprint or recipe for constructing a human body or any of its organs or cells. Straight talk about the physical limitations of brains and their contents leads to the conclusion that brains cannot be the source of human minds and cannot be any storage place of human memories. The two conclusions are mutually reinforcing.  If (partially because of the vast levels of hierarchical organization in human bodies) we cannot credibly explain the physical origin of any adult human body (and we certainly cannot), then it is all the more plausible that we lack any physical explanation for the origin of any human mind and lack any physical explanation for the wonders of human memory. 

What does a gene specify? A particular gene merely half-specifies the structure of a protein molecule. A gene merely specifies which amino acids make up a protein molecule, but that is merely a half-specification, because such a sequence of amino acids does not constitute the three-dimensional shape of a protein molecule. Protein molecules have a vast variety of extremely complex folded three-dimensional shapes, and no one has ever credibly explained how such shapes could be specified by a mere sequence of amino acids. The problem of how such 3D shapes arise is the still-unsolved problem called the protein folding problem. A related problem is the problem of how incredibly complex cells and anatomy can arise without there being any bodily specification for them. I call that the missing specifications problem, and explain it here. 

complex protein

Appendix; Since the false claim that DNA is a blueprint or program or recipe for building bodies continues to be told, I will need to cite again a list I have compiled of distinguished scientists and other PhD's or MD's who have told us such an idea is untrue. Below is the list (I will boldface underline the references to recipes):
  1. On page 26 of the recent book The Developing Genome, Professor David S. Moore states, "The common belief that there are things inside of us that constitute a set of instructions for building bodies and minds -- things that are analogous to 'blueprints' or 'recipes' -- is undoubtedly false."
  2. Biologist Rupert Sheldrake says this "DNA only codes for the materials from which the body is constructed: the enzymes, the structural proteins, and so forth," and "There is no evidence that it also codes for the plan, the form, the morphology of the body."
  3. Describing conclusions of biologist Brian Goodwin, the New York Times says, "While genes may help produce the proteins that make the skeleton or the glue, they do not determine the shape and form of an embryo or an organism." 
  4. Professor Massimo Pigliucci (mainstream author of numerous scientific papers on evolution) has stated  that "old-fashioned metaphors like genetic blueprint and genetic programme are not only woefully inadequate but positively misleading." Regarding the "DNA as body recipe" claim he has stated this: "The expression of specific genes in the course of development resembles nothing like the way a cook handles the ingredients of a recipe. Living organisms are also highly differentiated in a number of functional parts or components (cell types, tissues, etc.), in contrast with the homogenous cake that comes out of the oven. Moreover, the genome is not written in anything like a 'language,' as in the case of a recipe, and it certainly does not contain a description of the desired end product in any meaningful sense of the word 'description.’ "
  5. Neuroscientist Romain Brette states, "The genome does not encode much except for amino acids."
  6. In a 2016 scientific paper, three scientists state the following: "It is now clear that the genome does not directly program the organism; the computer program metaphor has misled us...The genome does not function as a master plan or computer program for controlling the organism; the genome is the organism's servant, not its master.
  7. In the book Mind in Life by Evan Thompson (published by the Belknap Press of Harvard University Press) we read the following on page 180: "The plain truth is that DNA is not a program for building organisms, as several authors have shown in detail (Keller 2000, Lewontin 1993, Moss 2003)."
  8. Developmental biologist C/H. Waddington stated, "The DNA is not a program or sequentially accessed control over the behavior of the cell."
  9.  Scientists Walker and Davies state this in a scientific paper: "DNA is not a blueprint for an organism; no information is actively processed by DNA alone...DNA is a passive repository for transcription of stored data into RNA, some (but by no means all) of which goes on to be translated into proteins."
  10. Geneticist Adam Rutherford states that "DNA is not a blueprint," a statement also made by biochemistry professor Keith Fox. 
  11. "The genome is not a blueprint," says Kevin Mitchell, a geneticist and neuroscientist at Trinity College Dublin, noting "it doesn't encode some specific outcome."
  12. "DNA cannot be seen as the 'blueprint' for life," says Antony Jose, associate professor of cell biology and molecular genetics at the University of Maryland, who says, "It is at best an overlapping and potentially scrambled list of ingredients that is used differently by different cells at different times."  
  13. Sergio Pistoi (a science writer with a PhD in molecular biology) tells us, "DNA is not a blueprint," and tells us, "We do not inherit specific instructions on how to build a cell or an organ." 
  14. Michael Levin (director of a large biology research lab) states that "genomes are not a blueprint for anatomy," and after referring to a "deep puzzle" of how biological forms arise, he gives this example: "Scientists really don’t know what determines the intricate shape and structure of the flatworm’s head."
  15. Ian Stevenson M.D. stated "Genes alone - which provide instructions for the production of amino acids and proteins -- cannot explain how the proteins produced by their instructions come to have the shape they develop and, ultimately, determine the form of the organisms where they are," and noted that "biologists who have drawn attention to this important gap in our knowledge of form have not been a grouping of mediocrities (Denton, 1986; Goldschmidt, 1952; B. C. Goodwin, 1985, 1988, 1989, 1994; Gottlieb, 1992; Grasse, 1973; E. S. Russell...Sheldrake, 1981; Tauber and Sarkar, 1992; Thompson, 1917/1942)."
  16. Biologist B.C. Goodwin stated this in 1989: "Since genes make molecules, genetics...does not tell us how the molecules are organized into the dynamic, organized process that is the living organism."
  17. An article in the journal Nature states this: "The manner in which bodies and tissues take form remains 'one of the most important, and still poorly understood, questions of our time', says developmental biologist Amy Shyer, who studies morphogenesis at the Rockefeller University in New York City."
  18. Timothy Saunders, a developmental biologist at the National University of Singapore says, "Fundamentally, we have a poor understanding of how any internal organ forms.”
  19. On the web site of the well-known biologist Denis Noble, we read that "the whole idea that genes contain the recipe or the program of life is absurd, according to Noble," and that we should understand DNA "not so much as a recipe or a program, but rather as a database that is used by the tissues and organs in order to make the proteins which they need."
  20. A paper by Stuart A. Newman (a professor of cell biology and anatomy) discussing at length the work of scientists trying to evoke "self-organization" as an explanation for morphogenesis states that "public lectures by principals of the field contain confidently asserted, but similarly oversimplified or misleading treatments," and says that "these analogies...give the false impression that there has been more progress in understanding embryonic development than there truly has been." Referring to scientists moving from one bunk explanation of morphogenesis to another bunk explanation, the paper concludes by stating, "It would be unfortunate if we find ourselves having emerged from a period of misconceived genetic program metaphors only to land in a brave new world captivated by equally misguided ones about self-organization."
  21. Referring to claims there is a program for building organisms in DNA, biochemist F. M. Harold stated "reflection on the findings with morphologically aberrant mutants suggests that the metaphor of a genetic program is misleading." Referring to  self-organization (a vague phrase sometimes used to try to explain morphogenesis), he says, "self-organization remains nearly as mysterious as it was a century ago, a subject in search of a paradigm." 
  22. Writing in the leading journal Cell, biologists  Marc Kirschner, John Gerhart and Tim Mitchison stated, "The genotype, however deeply we analyze it, cannot be predictive of the actual phenotype, but can only provide knowledge of the universe of possible phenotypes." That's equivalent to saying that DNA does not specify visible biological structures, but merely limits what structures an organism can have (just as a building parts list merely limits what structures can be made from the set of parts). 
  23. At the Stack Exchange expert answers site, someone posted a question asking which parts of a genome specify how to make a cell (he wanted to write a program that would sketch out a cell based on DNA inputs).  An unidentified expert stated that it is "not correct" that DNA is a blueprint that describes an organism, and that "DNA is not a blueprint because DNA does not have instructions for how to build a cell." No one contradicted this expert's claim, even though the site allows any of its experts to reply. 
  24. A paper co-authored by a chemistry professor (Jesper Hoffmeyer) tells us this: "Ontogenetic 'information,' whether about the structure of the organism or about its behavior, does not exist as such in the genes or in the environment, but is constructed in a given developmental context, as critically emphasized, for example, by Lewotin (1982) and Oyama (1985)."
  25. Biologist Steven Rose has stated, "DNA is not a blueprint, and the four dimensions of life (three of space, one of time) cannot be read off from its one-dimensional strand."
  26. Jonathan Latham has a master's degree in Crop Genetics and a PhD in virology. In his essay “Genetics Is Giving Way to a New Science of Life,” a long essay well worth a read, Latham exposes many of the myths about DNA. Referring to "the mythologizing of DNA," he says that "DNA is not a master controller," and asks, "How is it that, if organisms are the principal objects of biological study, and the standard explanation of their origin and operation is so scientifically weak that it has to award DNA imaginary superpowers of 'expression'” and 'control' to paper over the cracks, have scientists nevertheless clung to it?"
  27. An interesting 2006 paper by six medical authorities and scientists tells us that "biochemistry cannot provide the spatial information needed to explain morphogenesis," that "supracellular morphogenesis is mysterious," and that "nobody seems to understand the origin of biological and cellular order," contrary to claims that such order arises from a reading of a specification in DNA. 
  28. Keith Baverstock (with a PhD in chemical kinetics) has stated "genes are like the merchants that provide the necessary materials to build a house: they are neither the architect, nor the builder but, without them, the house cannot be built," and that "genes are neither the formal cause (the blueprint), nor the efficient cause (the builder) of the cell, nor of the organism."
  29. Evolutionary biologist Richard Lewontin stated, "DNA is not self-reproducing; second, it makes nothing; and third, organisms are not determined by it." Noting that "the more accurate description of the role of DNA is that it bears information that is read by the cell machinery," Lewontin lamented the "evangelical enthusiasm" of those who "fetishized DNA" and misspoke so that "DNA as information bearer is transmogrified into DNA as blueprint, as plan, as master plan, as master molecule." In another work he stated "the information in DNA sequences is insufficient to specify even a folded protein, not to speak of an entire organism." This was correct: DNA does not even specify the 3D shapes of proteins, but merely their sequence of amino acids. 
  30. In 2022 developmental biologist Claudio D. Stern first noted,  "All cells in an organism have the same genetic information yet they generate often huge complexity as they diversify in the appropriate locations at the correct time and generate form and pattern as well as an array of identities, dynamic behaviours and functions." In his next sentence he stated, "The key quest is to find the 'computer program' that contains the instructions to build an organism, and the mechanisms responsible for its evolution over longer periods." Since this was written long after the Human Genome Project had been completed, he thereby suggested that no such instruction program had yet been discovered in the genome (DNA). 
  31. Referring to developmental biologist Alfonso Martínez Arias, a 2024 article says, "Martínez Arias, 68, argues that the DNA sequence of an individual is not an instruction manual or a construction plan for their body...The Madrid-born biologist argues that there is nothing in the DNA molecule that explains why the heart is located on the left, why there are five fingers on the hand or why twin brothers have different fingerprints." In the article here, Arias says, "DNA cannot send orders to cells to move right or left within your body or to place the heart and the liver on opposite sides of your thorax. DNA cannot measure the length of your arms or instruct the placement of your eyes symmetrically across the midline of your face. We know this because each and every cell of an organism generally has the same DNA in it, with the same monotonous structure....The genome is not actually a blueprint for an organism or its architect."
  32. Two scientists said this: "We see no valid use for definitions of the genotype and phenotype in terms of blueprints, programs, or sets of instructions, and their realizations or manifestation....The program/manifestation metaphor is factually misleading, because it suggests that the genotype uniquely determines an organism’s phenotype. However, as is well known, all it does is specify an organism’s norm of reaction to environmental conditions (Rieger et al., 1991,Lewontin, 1992)."
  33. A 2022 paper in the journal Science (one authored by more than ten scientists) says this: "Although the genome is often called the blueprint of an organism, it is perhaps more accurate to describe it as a parts list composed of the various genes that may or may not be used in the different cell types of a multicellular organism....The genome in and of itself does not provide an understanding of the molecular complexity of the various cell types of that organism."
  34. A Duke University biologist and a Cornell University biologist have confessed this: " No information about the overall architecture of these body parts is present in the cells and tissues of the parts themselves, or in each organism’s genes."  
  35. Physics PhD Eric Heden states, "The molecular coding within DNA, rich and vast as it is, falls impossibly short of being able to supply the informational guidance needed to supervise the development and moment-by-moment cellular activities of living organisms."
  36. In their book "The Plausibility of Life: Resolving Darwin's Dilemma" (page 148)  biologists  Marc W. Kirschner and John C. Gerhart state, "DNA provides no instruction on where to place the proteins in the cell. There is no genetic information for large-scale cellular organization." 
  37. In his PhD thesis "Using Genetic Algorithms to Evolve Microstructures," David Basanta states, "Cells contain their genetic material in long strings of DNA located in several places inside the cell but mainly in the nucleus. This DNA does not specify the features of the cell or the multicellular organism in which the cell is a constituent part." 
  38. Anthropologist Ann Horsburgh states, "The metaphor of genes as blueprints is powerfully seductive but wholly inaccurate. Genes do not specify organismal morphology or behavior."
  39. Werner A. Müller (chairman of the Department of Physiology at the University of Heidelberg)   on page 2 of his textbook on developmental biology states this: "It is commonly stated that the genome incorporates a Bauplan, an architectural plan or blueprint of the body. Actually, this is not the case; the genome is not a sketch or design of the finished body. The information capacity of DNA is simply too low to store blueprints of the very complex final pattern of an organism." On the same page after describing how limited is the information in DNA (the genome), he notes that "we do not yet understand in detail how a developing organism is created on the basis of such minimal information."
  40. Physician James Le Fanu has stated,  "There is, in short, nothing in the genomes of fly and man to account for why a fly should have two wings, four legs and a dot-sized brain and we should have two arms, two legs and a mind capable of understanding the origins of the universe." 
  41. In a scientific paper on heritability entitled "The Heritability Fallacy," David S. Moore (holder of a mathematics PhD from Cornell University) has stated this:" Our DNA, we now know, does not contain specific blueprint-like instructions about traits; rather, DNA segments merely contribute to the production of different kinds of RNA molecules. These RNA molecules can, in turn, regulate other DNA segments, or contribute to the production of proteins that are constituent parts of cells, cells that are assembled into systems that manifest identifiable traits." Later in the same paper he refers to "the demonstrably false notion that genes have some direct and isolated influence on traits."
  42. In a 2024 scientific paper two scientists confessed that "morphogenesis does not have a hardwired blueprint, it is not a linear readout of genetic information." Later they said, "The complex morphological patterns of organs emerge during development and cannot be deduced from its cellular and molecular constituents." As an alternative to "DNA as blueprint" myths, they offered this very vacuous-sounding explanation: "Instead, cells constantly adapt to surrounding cues to buffer against stochastic fluctuations and self-organise into a variety of macroscopic structures." That is a bit of empty hand-waving that fails to explain how there arises anatomy so fine-tuned and functional, and also fails to explain how so many types of enormously organized cells arise.
  43. On page 94 of his book "What Genes Can't Do," former cell biologist Lenny Moss stated this: "The standard rationale for speaking of genes in the conflationary style -- as the 'information,' 'blueprint,' 'program,' 'instructions,' and so forth for building an organism -- is that DNA provides the template for synthesizing proteins and that proteins, as enzymes, regulate all of the chemical reactions of the cell. For this rationale to hold up it must be the case that either (1) spatial arrangements of enzymes in the cell are of no great consequence or (2) that spatial arrangement is somehow prefigured and predetermined by the one-dimensional array...in the genes. A principal objective of this chapter is to provide evidence and an argument to the effect that neither of these is the case." In the book's introduction, he stated, "The seemingly prevalent idea that genes constitute information for traits (and blueprints for organisms) is based, I argue, on an unwarranted conflation...held together by rhetorical glue."