Neuroscientists Cannot Credibly Explain Any of These 11 Features of Out-of-Body Experiences

The most popular strategy used by those trying to explain accounts of the paranormal is the strategy of shrunken description. Given accounts that are utterly beyond the power of some skeptic to explain, the skeptic will try the technique of describing the type of observation so that only some strange little fraction of the whole phenomenon is reported. 

An example of following such a strategy was Michael Faraday's feeble attempt to explain the mysterious events involving tables that were massively reported by a host of observers in the middle of the nineteenth century. Each of these phenomena was massively reported by very many witnesses at very many different times and very many different places (as described in my posts here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here & here):

(1) Mysterious raps coming from untouched tables, and from many other places in a room. 

(2) Strange sudden movements of a table when a group of people merely put their finger tips on the table's top. 

(3) Tables moving around a room "by themselves," both when people touched the tables with their finger tips, and when no one touched the table. 

(4) Tables rising up on two legs, when no one was touching the table. 

(5) Tables levitating up into the air, when no one was touching the table. 

Faraday used the method of shrunken description to try to discredit such reports. He described the phenomenon as only involving item 2 above (table movements while hands were on a table), and attempted to account for it by involuntary muscle movement. He simply ignored all of the other phenomenon. Faraday's explanation is a joke to any serious scholar of these observation reports, because his explanation fails completely to account for items (1), (3), (4) and (5) above. 

A similar strategy is typically used by a person trying to give explanations for out-of-body experiences while sticking to the dogma that the brain is the source of the mind. The person will describe an out-of-body experience in some shrunken way, without mentioning most aspects of the experience. He will then make some attempt at a neural explanation. For example, he may describe an out-of-body experience as a mere "feeling of floating," and may then try to explain why your brain might give you a "feeling of floating." 

To rebut such sins of shrunken description, let me discuss all of the features that are often reported when out-of-body experiences are described. Not every account of an out-of-body experience will involve all of these features. But each of these features is something that is often reported when people report out-of-body experiences. Since I am trying to document many examples of particular features of out-of-body experiences, I may duplicate a quotation a few times, in cases when a quotation involves more than one of these features. 

Each of the features is beyond any credible neural explanation. About most of these features we can say: no one would report such a thing if the mind is a product of the brain. The examples I will give of such features are only a tiny fraction of the reports of out-of-body experiences that have reported such features, and I could easily give ten examples for every example I will give. 

Feature #1: observing one's own body from outside it, typically from a horizontal position, at a distance of about two meters above it, or from a location near the ceiling.

Below are some relevant examples:

(1) On page 288 of the July, 1894 edition of the Journal of the Society for Psychical Research, which can be read here, a witness reported being an observer above his own body, with an "elastic force" preventing him from floating too far away from his body. He reported he could not rise higher than "two yards" above his body. 

(2) On page 34 of the January 17, 1903 edition of the periodical Light, which can be read here, George Wyld MD describes having an out-of-body experience in which his "soul-form" was "six or seven feet" above his body. 

(3) On page 46 of the February 8, 1919 edition of the periodical Light, which can be read here,  we hear an account by Captain Gilbert Nobbs of getting a severe head injury during World War I. He says, "I seemed for a moment somewhere in the emptiness looking down at my body lying in the shell-hole."

(4) On pages 57-58 of an Italian book (the text of which can be easily translated using Google Translate), we read that Mrs. Nathalie Annenkof reported an out-of-body experience, saying "suddenly I found myself above and next to my body, which I saw sitting on the edge of the grave... And I had the sensation of hovering above my body in complete bliss."

(5) On page 23 of the periodical here we read this:

" 'On one occasion at a dentist’s office.' says Arthur J. Wills, Ph.D., C.E., of 224 Herrick Road, Riverside, Illinois, 'the dentist was drilling in my tooth. Suddenly I found myself outside of myself looking over the dentist’s shoulder into my own mouth!' "

(6)  On the same page of that periodical, we read an account by a Mr. Hyman who says, "I found myself high up in the room, from where, to my terror, I saw my body on the bed, eyes closed. " 

(7) Barbara Lambert said that during a difficult labor she floated out of her body to the ceiling, and saw her body from above, temporarily thinking that the body below her was her twin sister (link). 

(8) A woman (W.H. Westley) said that at her son's funeral her heart fluttered, and she found herself high above the funeral attendees, addressed by the very son who had died (link).

(9) Ami Greenstead suffered from a rare illness causing many fainting experiences, but reported to her mother that she had out-of-body experiences during such events, going up to the ceiling and observing her body from above (link). 

(10) Bryce Bond reports that when hospitalized from an allergic reaction, he rose up out of his body to the ceiling, before traveling through a dark tunnel, and meeting a dead relative he recognized (link).

(11) Dick Battista reported floating above the operating table during a transplant operation and watching the surgeons do their work (link).

(12) Marjorie Hall reported that she had an out-of-body experience during childbirth. She says, "I felt myself lift out of my body and float upward." She reported seeing from above her body giving birth, at a height about 15 feet (about five meters) above the scene (link). 

(13) On page 95  of a book we read this account by Cromwell Anderson:

"One night I awoke to find myself floating over my body, a few feet from the ceiling and could see my physical body on the bed beneath me. 

(14) Below is an account of a man who was in an armored car hit by an an anti-tank shell:

 "I was conscious of being two persons -- one, lying on the ground in a field where I had fallen from the blast, my clothes, etc., on fire ...The other 'me' was floating up in the air, about twenty feet from my body, from which position I could see not only my other self on the ground, but also the hedge, the road, and the car, which was surrounded by smoke and burning fiercely."

The person reported telling himself to roll to put out the fire, and then once he did,  his perception returned to normal. The account appeared on page 207 of the March-April 1948 edition of the Journal of the Society for Psychical Research, which can be read here. 

On page 123 of the 1954 Proceedings of the American Society for Psychical Research (Volume 48), which you can read here, we read of a poll done of 42 students who were asked: "Have you ever actually seen your physical body from a viewpoint completely outside that body, like standing beside the bed and looking at yourself lying in the bed, or like floating in the air near your body?” 33% answered "Yes." 

In 1968 there appeared the book Out-of-the-Body Experiences by Celia Green, the Director of the Institute of Psychophysical Research at Oxford University. Registered users at www.archive.org can read the book here. In 1966 an appeal had been made by radio for accounts of people who had such experiences. About 400 responses were received. Two questionnaires were sent to these people, and 326 replied to the first, with 251 to the second. On pages 42 to 43 she stated this:

On page 46 Green says this:

 "The great majority of subjects describe themselves as looking down on their physical bodies. The subject frequently refers to his ecsomatic position as being near the ceiling -- e.g 'suspended against the ceiling.' Again, the corner of the ceiling is often specified."

On page 107 of Green's book we have this account:

"I remember nothing whatsoever of the process of leaving my body, but 'awoke' early next morning being fully conscious of the real me floating near the ceiling in a prone position. The sensation was of total weightlessness and freedom, and was altogether most delightful. I observed my physical body lying on the bed sleeping peacefully, on my left side as usual, but was struck by the extreme pallor the skin of my face which looked as if it would have been stone-cold to the touch."

Robert Crookall noted quite a few observers who reported floating horizontally above their bodies at a distance of about one or two meters:

"A number described their newly released 'doubles' as occupying a remarkable position, namely horizontal, just above the vacated body. They were J. McCormack (who noted 'this rather odd position'), Miss Bazett (about three feet above), Mrs. C. H. Smith (about a foot above), Mulvey (about three feet above), Dennis, Mr. 'H,' Mrs. Boorman, Dr. Gilbert, Mrs. Hibberd, Miss Douglas, Nurse Normanby, Mrs. 'Horam,' Miss Dean, G. Lester, and Mrs. Folson ( when she was a child of five or six years). More than a score of others, who did not describe the horizontal position, did note that their 'doubles' were above their bodies."

Below are some cases from one of the books of Robert Crookall:

• Case #161. A Mrs. J. Douglas Newton reported this: "My son, then 8 years of age, who had never heard of any¬ thing of this sort, had gone to bed one night and was lying reading. Suddenly he called rather urgently for me. I found him sitting up, rather scared. He said, 'Such a funny thing has happened. I was just lying reading when I felt I was rising into the air. I seemed to go up, near the ceiling. Then I looked down and could see myself lying in bed. I came slowly down.' "
• Case #162. A B. Barrett reported this: "I was in perfect health when one night I found myself looking down at my earthly body and could not make out why it was not lying there dead as I thought."
• Case 165. A Mrs. Lambert reported this: "Suddenly I shot out of my body. I lay about six feet up, looking down at myself."
• Case 170. A Peter Urquhart stated this: "I went outside and found myself out of the body again. This time the sensation was like being in a balloon, attached by a cord somewhere in the region of the navel, like the umbilical cord."
• Case 172. A Mrs. Argles reported this: "I found myself standing on the top of the steps, looking down on my body, lying on the floor. There was a cord connecting me to the body on the floor."
• Case 173. Vera Oates stated this: "In the early hours of the morning I was suddenly wide awake, but, to my amazement, I was hovering between the railing and the bed. I looked down and saw myself on the bed."
• Case 175. A Mrs. Harris stated this: "I have left my body many times, walking round the room and looking at my body which is joined by a cord." Reports of such a cord connecting body to soul are not very rare.
• Case 183. A Mrs. M. F. Hemeon stated this: "Suddenly I felt myself  ‘swimming’ up out of my body...I was very startled, and by an effort of will... returned to my body."
• Case 194. A woman states, " Suddenly I was floating with my nose almost touching the ceiling—I saw all the little imperfections in the distemper."
• Case 201: An R. J. Carlson states, " I suddenly found myself out of and above myself—and yet I could either sense or see my body in bed."
• Case 204: A Rebecca Schreiber stated "I suddenly felt I had left my body and was flying over the ocean until I came to the ship" (the Queen Mary) that her daughter was on. After asking her daughter what was wrong, and being told she was sea-sick, she told her daughter she would soon feel better. Her daughter later said she had an experience matching this visitation account, while on the ship, at about the same time. 
• Case 236. Oscar Mockler stated, "The next thing I was aware of was standing on the floor of the cabin and looking down at my body lying asleep in the bunk."
• Case 241.  Mrs. N. Matile stated this: "I found myself floating above my bed (about three feet above). I then quickly passed out of the window to the middle of the Mews where we were living. It was a starry night and it was a lovely feeling, floating in the air. "
• Case 243. An M.E. Fearn stated this: "I felt myself arise and float off the bed and ... was at the foot of our bed, looking at myself asleep, facing my husband’s back. Then I floated towards the window."
• Case 246.  A Mrs. Eyres stated, "I had a feeling that the real Me came out of my body through the head and I had the sensation of flying.” She claimed to have visited other countries in out-of-body experiences. 
• Case 247. A Mrs. Watkin claimed to be visited by two figures who took on a visit to some spirit world. She states this: "I was brought back to my bedroom and there the three of us again stood looking at my lifeless-looking body. Suddenly I slipped easily and swiftly into it."   
• Case 259. A Miss Douglas stated this: "“One night I awoke from sleep to find that I was in a horizontal position and suspended in mid-air. In this position I travelled at moderate speed through the bedroom windows out into the night. It was moonlight and I could see the houses very clearly. I felt thrilled as I travelled along ...It was so real. I drifted across the roof-tops and identified the neighbours’ gardens. ... On the return journey I seemed to be losing height but not speed. ... Finally, I arrived in the garden at home, still remaining in a horizontal position and suspended in mid-air."
• Case 267. A Mr. Hall stated this: "Presently a most strange sensation passed through my body. Next I floated out through the window and across the town. I seemed to be several hundred feet above the ground."
• Case 269. A Mrs. Flint stated, "One afternoon, while resting on my bed, I felt myself floating, or rather suspended in the air, and I was actually looking down at my body on the bed."
• Case 285. A Mrs. Mansergh stated this: "In February, 1939, my husband and I retired to bed as usual and I awoke to find myself standing by the side of the bed looking down on the sleeping forms of my husband and myself. I moved away from the bed to the window. As I moved, I noticed a glistening cord trailing from me." 
• Case 309. A G. Bradley stated this: " I awoke about 7 a.m., and had the sensation of leaving the body. All I could see was the frame of myself left in the bed. I was floating around the room feeling peaceful. Suddenly I had the urge to get back into the shell of my body. What a struggle I had to do it!"
• Case 310. A Mrs. Shakespeare stated this: "During the night I seemed to float down the ward and then returned and hovered over my bed, looking down at myself. I felt calm and peaceful.”
• Case 313: A Mrs. Fyal stated this:  "Suddenly I felt myself leaving my body and looking around my bedroom... I saw my own body...Suddenly I found myself wandering again and floated to my body where, in the morning, I was astounded that I was in it."
• Case 314: A Mrs. Langridge stated this: "I was outside my body, suspended in air, and looking down upon my body. Three or four people were reviving me. I was in a pleasant state of freedom and thought, ‘I wish these people would leave me alone!' "
• Case 327. Dr G. B. Kirkland stated this: "To my surprise, I found myself looking at myself lying on the bed. The thought; just flashed through me that I didn't think much of me —in fact, I didn’t approve of me at all. Then I was hurried off at great speed. Have you ever looked through a very long tunnel and seen the tiny speck of light at the far end ? It seems an incredible distance off. Well, I found myself with others vaguely discernible hurrying along just such a tunnel or passage—smoky or cloudy, colourless, grey and very cold."
• Case 336: An F. W. Talbot stated this: "The next  moment I was suspended in mid-air, horizontal, and looking down at my body on the bed. I could see myself lying in bed quite clearly. I watched an attendant go to my body, lift my arm and plunge in a needle. This was extremely interesting; I was suspended over his head and my feeling was that of detached curiosity."
• Case 337: A Mrs Rowbotham stated, "I remember being on the ceiling of the room looking down at the two doctors and two nurses—just floating and watching."
• Case 339: A Kathleen Snowdon stated this: "Suddenly I realized a feeling of great excitement, wonder and delight surpassing anything I had ever experienced as I felt my body [‘double’] completely weightless and floating upwards in a golden glow towards a wonderful light around hazy welcoming figures and the whole air was filled with beautiful singing. I floated joyfully towards the light and then I heard my mother’s voice calling me. My whole being revolted against going back."
• Case 343: An S. H. Kelly stated this: "As I lost consciousness, certain things in my life came in front of me. This was followed by a queer sound of music and the next thing I was suspended in mid-air and looking at them bringing my body out of the water and trying artificial respiration. I was very happy and free and wondered why they were doing that when I was here! At that moment I was transported to my mother’s room. I stood beside her as she was by the fire in an easy chair, trying to tell her I was all right and happy. Afterwards, I was back, looking at my body, when a brilliant light shone around me and a voice said, ‘It is not your time yet—you must go back. You have work to do!' "
• Case 346:  A Mrs. Maries stated this: "Meanwhile I  had left my body and felt myself floating in what seemed like a dark tunnel (with a glimpse, at the end, of a lovely countryside). I had no pain, only a wonderful feeling of happiness. I felt I had somebody with me, but saw nobody. Only I heard a voice which said, ‘You must go back! That child needs you!’ I returned to my body and heard the doctor say, ‘No, by Jove, I can still feel her heart!’ "

The number and consistency of these accounts I have quoted is very high, ruling out any explanation of hallucination. Hallucinations produce random content, not accounts that would appear with such consistency as we find in the accounts above.  

Feature #2:  a strong feeling of euphoria or exaltation during an out-of-body experience 

I have already quoted several cases above of people reporting an exhilaration or euphoria during an out-of-body experience, including a mention of "a wonderful feeling of happiness" by Mrs. Maries. a feeling by S. H. Kelley that she was "very happy," a feeling of "great excitement, wonder and delight surpassing anything I have ever experienced" by Kathleen Snowdon, and  a statement by Miss Douglas that she "felt thrilled," Below are some more relevant examples:

(1) On page 40 of the January 22, 1932 edition of the periodical Light, which you can read here, a doctor describes an out-of-body experience, saying, "I cannot describe the sensation of peace and happiness." 

(2) On page 46 of the February 8, 1919 edition of the periodical Light, which can be read here,  we hear an account by Captain Gilbert Nobbs of getting a severe head injury during World War I. Just before saying, "I seemed for a moment somewhere in the emptiness looking down at my body lying in the shell-hole," Nobbs says, "There was a peacefulness... a happiness indescribable."

(3) On pages 57-58 of an Italian book (the text of which can be easily translated using Google Translate), we read that Mrs. Nathalie Annenkof reported an out-of-body experience, says this:

"I had the sensation of hovering above my body in complete bliss. I had the sensation of a great and luminous joy of living, as if I were living a thousand lives at once, and of complete tranquility." 

(4) On page 63 of a book, we read an account by Joseph Costa of an out-of-body experience. He says, "If I said that I felt free, light, ethereal, I would only be expressing from afar the sensation that I felt in this moment of infinite liberation...I never had such a vivid sensation of really existing as in the moment when I felt separated from my body."

(5)  On page 59 of the November - December 1945 edition of the Journal of the Society for Psychical Research, which you can read here, we have this account of bliss during an out-of-body experience:

"Then, I can only describe this my own way, I was given psychic vision, for my Spirit left my body which I saw by my wife's in bed. I seemed to resemble the shape of a flame with a long silver thread attached to my earth body. I enjoyed, what I can only liken to, the Peace of God which passeth all understanding, I have never enjoyed such mental exhilaration before or since." 

(6) A man having an out-of-body experience said that he felt more alive than ever before (link).

(7)  Case 346 mentioned above mentioned "a wonderful feeling of happiness" during an out-of-body experience.  

On page 39 in her book about out-of-body experiences, based on a survey of hundreds who had such experiences,  Green says, "Many subjects comment on their feelings of well-being and reality in their new position apart from their physical body, and there are no counter-instances, that is to say, no subjects remark on having felt incomplete, unsubstantial or unreal in their new position." On page 86 she quotes someone who had an out-of-body experience saying that she felt "the utmost joy and happiness." On page 87 she quotes someone having an out-of-body experience as saying, "The escaped me felt absolutely wonderful, very light and full of the most wonderful vitality, in fact more well than I have ever felt before or since."

Feature #3:  an experience of being able to pass-through matter while having an out-of-body experience.

(1) In the article "Astral Excursions" by Franz Hartmann MD, which appears on page 159 of the March 1908 Occult Review, which can be read here, Hartmann describes an out-of-body experience. He says that during this experience "when I tried to lift one of the instruments on a little table next to the chair, I could not do so, as my fingers passed through it."  

(2) A report of an out-of-body experience can be read in the 1936 book 'Twixt Earth and Heaven by Annie Britain, which you can read here. On page 50 she states this:

"I tried to grasp and move some cups and saucers in the room, but my fingers passed through them as if they were shadows. On the same occasion I tried to slap and pinch the faces of the people in the room but could make no impression on them, and they did not take the least notice of me. I walked through a table as though it were an optical illusion. I remember feeling amused to think that I was so superior to flesh and blood, which usually comes off second best in encounter with wood, stone or steel. Tables, chairs, walls, the bodies of humans, seem as unsubstantial as shadows when one is out of the body."

On page 56 the author states this:

"I woke to find myself standing outside my body, gazing at the sleeping form in the chair. My cousin was by my side, a young man who had died some years before, and to whom I had been deeply attached. I was not greatly surprised to see him, as he had often escorted me on my spirit travels. Now he offered to take me out for the afternoon and see some of the spirit people. We passed out through the walls of the room, seeming to glide rather than to walk, with no more sense of motion than if we had been in a balloon."

(3) On page 69 of Green's book we read this account of someone able to pass his hand through solid matter while having an out-of-body experience:

(4) On page 124 of the October, 1954 edition of the Journal of the American Society for Psychical Research, we read this:

"Of the students who reported having seen their physical bodies from outside positions, more than one-fourth said that during such experiences they seemed to be occupying another body, which seemed to be real, tangible, and capable of voluntary movement. More than two out of five reported that, during their out-of-the-body experiences they seemed to be able to pass through seemingly solid objects—like closed doors, or blank walls."

(5) On page 47 of the study here, we have one person's account of an out-of-body experience, one that has Feature #1, Feature #3, and Feature #4.

"I was very awake standing at the bathroom sink getting ready to shave. With no warning I soon found myself looking at my physical body from about 3 feet in front of me and slightly elevated. After assessing my facial expression which did not change I moved towards the other side of the bathroom noticing how incredibly vivid the wall paper appeared. I then was confronted with the shower wall and decided to continue realizing that I could go right through the wall."

(6) On pages 254 to 255 of the 1895 book Brown Studies by George H. Hepworth, we have a description of an out-of-body experience, one that includes an account of being able to pass through matter. We read this:

"While sitting with my right hand resting on the arm of the chair I seemed to step out of my body, and stand beside it, looking upon it with mingled curiosity and astonishment. I felt as light as air, and said to myself, 'This must be what St. Paul calls the spiritual body.' It is true that I looked on what sat in the chair with a kind of tenderness, but the sense of freedom which I soon became conscious of was almost ecstatic, and it seemed as though I would not go back into those narrow quarters again for worlds. The body was so clumsy, so heavy, so un comely, so uncouth and ungraceful, while this other body, on the contrary, was a delight, a dream, a poem....I moved away from my body toward the door, thinking to open it and go out into the starlight ; but to my surprise I found that the door was no obstruction whatever. I simply passed through it as the sun's rays pass through a pane of glass."

Feature #4:  an experience of having enhanced senses during an out-of-body experience, which may include the ability to see through walls or look inside the body as if you had x-ray eyes, or the ability to see a 360 degree view.

(1) On page 70 of a book an author quotes Eugenie Garcia as having an out-of-body experience, apparently while being hypnotized:

"  I cast my eyes on myself: 'Look! I am luminous, transparent, light as a feather.'  Suddenly, I saw my body lying motionless in an armchair. Three or four people surrounded me, watching me attentively. What are they looking at me like that? Let's see. I come closer and look at myself too. doing like everyone else. I could clearly see the inside of my body, I could see the heart beating, the blood circulating, the networks.."

(2) On page 63 of a book, we read an account by Joseph Costa an out-of-body experience. Speaking as if he had X-ray vision, he says, "I saw my body perfectly recognizable by its particularities, its profile, my figure, but also bundles of veins and nerves vibrating with a luminous tingling."

(3) On page 62 of his book Lessons From the Light, Kenneth Ring quotes an account received by him in a letter, in which a woman described an out-of-body experience (when she says "three hundred degree" she apparently means "three-hundred-sixty degree"):

"I was hovering over a stretcher in one of the emergency rooms

at the hospital. I glanced down at the stretcher, knew the body

wrapped in blankets was mine, and really didn't care...I could see

the tiles on the ceiling and the tiles on the floor, simultaneously:

three hundred degree spherical vision. And not just spherical. Detailed! I could see every single hair and the follicle out of which it grew on the head of the nurse standing beside the stretcher."

(4) On page 37 of the same book, Ring quotes a male witness who claimed to see a womanly figure of light during his out-of-body experience. He recalls this when looking at his body:

"I could see the vascular system and the chambers emptying and filling with blood. I could see the vascular system and the life-sustaining materials working their way through the entire body. "

(5) On page 60 of the same book, a nearsighted woman recalls "the next I was aware of was floating on the ceiling" and that at this time "it was so vivid" and that "I could read the numbers on the machine behind my head." 

(6) On pages 254 to 255 of the 1895 book Brown Studies by George H. Hepworth, we have a description of an out-of-body experience. On page 255 he seems to describe enhanced vision during such an experience:

"I shall never be able to tell you how the stars looked that night. The heavens were an astonishing revelation to me. Not only did I see with perfectly clear vision, but there seemed to be a penetrating, a far-reaching quality to my sight which doubled the number of glistening lights above me, and the spectacle was so marvelous, so beautiful, that I stood entranced."

On page 256 the author compares his enhanced vision during his out-of-body experience to an account he heard of a very nearsighted boy who was given glasses and who could suddenly see the world clearly for the first time. 

(7) In the account below (from page 393 of the paper here) a person having an out-of-body experience reports having enhanced hearing (the account has both Feature #1 and Feature #4):

(8) One person having an out-of-body experience said this: "I was suddenly not in my body but above it...I could see, but all around, as

if my mind ...had eye-facets all over."

On page 72 of Green's book on out-of-body experiences, we read this:

On page 79 of Green's book she quotes someone who claims to have seen through a wall during an out-of-body experience. 

Around page 59 of his book Lessons From the Light, Kenneth Ring begins discussing cases that seemed to show superior vision during out-of-body experiences. He mentions some cases of people who reported being able to see very clearly the dust that was in some high spot above their bodies, such as the dust on a hanging lamp. On page 60 he estimates that he encountered about six cases of what he calls the "dust on the light fixture" type. On the same page he quotes someone as saying that she could see in vivid detail during her our-of-body experience, even though she is very nearsighted, and at time was not wearing her glasses. On page 61 he quotes a first-person account of someone else who claimed he could see very clearly during an out-of-body experience, even though he was very myopic and not wearing glasses. 

On page 76 of Green's book, she quotes someone who claims to have seen clearly in the dark during an out-of-body experience outdoors. On page 78 she quotes someone who claims to have been able to see "in a full circle of 360" degrees during an out-of-body experience. 

The study "Differences and Commonalities Among Various Types of Perceived Out-of-Body Experiences (OBEs) (Phase II)" analyzed 252 reports of out-of-body experiences, received by those who filled out questionnaires after responding to advertising asking for responses from people who had out-of-body experiences.  On page 24 we read this: "Some of the participants reported they were able to see a much wider area than before. This even included a visual perception spanning up to 360° in some cases. Although there was a question about the clarity of sight asked during both phases, the question did not mention anything about the field of their vision, so their comments about a broader form of sight were not directly solicited and their descriptions contain self-chosen terms (e.g., 360°, etc.)." There then follows several quotes from survey respondents talking about 360 degree vision or "fish-eye lens" vision, and two respondents talking about a binocular or zoom ability. Page 26 quotes a person as saying "everything seemed very vivid, a higher definition," and quotes another person as saying, "I could see very clear and it looked crystal clear like it was the best high definition ever." The same page quotes another person as saying, "I could see everything perfectly clearly, which is odd because my glasses had fallen off my face in the accident." 

Feature #5: an experience of being connected to the body while outside of it, sometimes with there being a cord-like or elastic structure between the observer outside of the body and his own body.

I have already cited above several cases in which Feature #5 was reported. Here are some more:

(1) On page 59 of the November - December 1945 edition of the Journal of the Society for Psychical Research, which you can read here, we have this account of a "long silver thread" between someone's spirit (outside of his body) and the body. 

"Then, I can only describe this my own way, I was given psychic vision, for my Spirit left my body which I saw by my wife's in bed. I seemed to resemble the shape of a flame with a long silver thread attached to my earth body." 

(2) On page 103 we read of a novelist named William Gerhardi who had an out-of-body experience, one in which he seemed to experience the "silver cord" often reported in out-of-body experiences:

"At the back of me was a coil of light, like a luminous garden hose resembling the strong broad ray of dusty light at the back of a dark cinema projecting on the screen in front. To my utter astonishment, that broad cable of light at the back of me illuminated the very face on the pillows I recognized as my own, as if attached to the brow of the sleeper."

(3) On pages 116-117 of a book he author, Sylvan Muldoon describes his first out-of-body experience:

"Slowly ...I was moving toward the ceiling, all the while lying horizontal and powerless. Naturally I believed that this was my physical body as I had always known it, but that it had mysteriously begun to defy gravity...Involuntarily, at about six feet above the bed, as if the movement had been conducted by an invisible intelligent force, present in the very air, I was uprighted from the horizontal position, to the perpendicular, and placed standing upon the floor of the room... where I remained for two or three minutes, still unable to move of my own accord... I managed to turn around. There were two of me! In the name of common sense — there were two of me! There was another 'me' lying quietly upon the bed. It was difficult to conceive of this being real — but there I was, fully conscious, fully able to reason and know what I saw was actual. The next thing which caught my eye, explained the curious sensation in the back of my head — for my two identical bodies were joined by means of an elastic-like cord, one end of which was fastened to the medulla oblongata region of my phantom counterpart, while the other end centered between the eyes of my physical counterpart. This cord extended across the space of probably six feet which separated us."

(4) In his 1864 biography Incidents in My Life, Daniel Dunglas Home related an out-of-body experience. After hearing a mysterious voice that seemed to be that of his late wife, he had an experience he described below:

"I was at this instant brought to a consciousness of light, by seeing the whole of my nervous system, as it were, composed of thousands of electrical scintillations, which here and there, as in the created nerve, took the form of currents, darting their rayons over the whole body in a manner most marvellous ; still this was but a cold electrical light and besides, it was external. Gradually, however, I saw that the extremities were less luminous, and the finer membranes' surrounding the brain became as it were glowing, and I felt that thought and action were no longer connected with the earthly tenement, but that they were in a spirit-body in every respect similar to the body which I knew to have been mine, and which I now saw lying motionless before me on the bed. The only link which held the two forms together seemed to be a silvery-like light, which proceeded from the brain ; and, as if it were a response to my earlier waking thoughts, the same voice, only that it was now more musical than before, said,  'Death is but a second birth, corresponding in every respect to the natural birth, and should the uniting link now be severed, you could never again enter the body.' "

(5) In Case 170 quoted above someone stated "the sensation was like being in a balloon, attached by a cord somewhere in the region of the navel, like the umbilical cord."

(6) In Case 172 quoted above a Mrs. Argles reported this: "I found myself standing on the top of the steps, looking down on my body, lying on the floor. There was a cord connecting me to the body on the floor."

(7) In Case 175 quoted above a Mrs. Harris stated this: "I have left my body many times, walking round the room and looking at my body which is joined by a cord." 

(8) In Case 285 quoted above a Mrs. Mansergh stated that during her out-of-body experience, "As I moved, I noticed a glistening cord trailing from me."

(9) On page 62 of the January 26, 1934 edition of the periodical Light, which you can read here, we have an account of an out-of-body experience in which the witness describes a cord between her regular body and herself out of the body.

At the end of his book More Astral Projections, Robert Crookall has some interesting summary statistics regarding how often such accounts had recurring characteristics. He used the term "the double" for a kind of spirit body that was a double of the human body. For what he called "single-type cases" the statistics included the following:

• "The fact that, the newly-released ‘double’, often took up a horizontal position (usually not far above its physical counterpart), was noted in 50 natural and 7 enforced cases (i.e. 23.3 per cent and 18.9 per cent respectively)."
• The percentage of people reporting a "silver cord" or "shining cord" connecting the human body and a spirit body (or something like that) was "43 (20.0 per cent) natural cases, 6 (16.2 per cent) enforced cases." 

On page 100 of Green's book, she reports a smaller incidence of such a "cord" effect. She reports that only about 30% of those having a single out-of-body experience felt any connection to their body, and that only 3.5% reported a visible connection to the body, such as a visible cord leading back to it. 

Feature #6:  an experience of encountering one or more spiritual or non-physical entities (or deceased people) while having an out-of-body experience.

I have already mentioned in this post several accounts which have this feature. Below are some more:

(1) On page 5 of a 1944 periodical (the May 10, 1944 Psychic Observer which can be read here) George B. Bronwell MD gives a narrative of a near-death experience and out-of-body experience.  He reported seeing his wife's sister, who had passed away several years earlier. He also reported being transported to some mystical realm. 

(2) A report of out-of-body experiences can be read in the 1936 book 'Twixt Earth and Heaven by Annie Britain, which you can read here. On page 56 she states this:

"I woke to find myself standing outside my body, gazing at the sleeping form in the chair. My cousin was by my side, a young man who had died some years before, and to whom I had been deeply attached."

(3) Olivia Robertson reported having an out-of-body experience that included a "long, long tunnel" and an encounter with her deceased mother (link). 

(4) Young Kanta Smith reported an out-of-body experience while "dead" for 15 minutes before being revived. She described meeting a grandfather she had never even seen in a photo, and a parent says the description matched that of the grandfather (link).

(5) On page 67 of a book we read of a New Jersey woman who reported an out-of-body experience during an operation. She recalls meeting a deceased grandmother who took her on a little flying tour that ended with the woman returning to her body. 

Feature #7:  an experience of completely leaving the location of the body, while traveling to other earthly locations or unearthly locations.

I have already reported above several cases that reported Feature #7. Below are some more.

(1) Marcel Picard reported having an out-of-body experience in which he floated above his body, eventually reaching other apartments below his (link). 

(2) Below is a May 20, 1935 account of a young boy's out-of-body experience, from page 342 of the periodical Light. The account includes a report of the observer transporting around mysteriously to other earthly locations. 

(3) Below is an account of a man claiming to have out-of-body experiences in which he traveled to the 1905 World's Fair in St. Louis. 

You can read the full account here:

https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn85058130/1905-02-05/ed-1/seq-18/

(4) Below is a 1903 account of a dying boy (Walter Smith) who reports a trip to Heaven during a close brush with death that was soon followed by actual death. We have elements of a near-death experience, an out-of-body experience and perhaps what is called terminal lucidity.  Click on the image to read it better. 

You can read the account below:

https://cdnc.ucr.edu/?a=d&d=SRX19030814.2.2&srpos=752&e=-------en--20--741--txt-txTI-psychic-------

(5) A person being viciously beaten by the Nazis reportedly had an out-of-body experience in which he returned to his home, only to see his wife cavorting there with another man (link)

(6) A nurse claimed that three different times she had an out-of-body experience when one of her patients was dying, saying that she kind of mystically traveled with them towards some otherworldly destination, before being told she must go back (link).

(7) A student claiming out-of-body experiences reportedly described correctly the home of her professor, which she had never physically seen, but claimed to have visited in an out-of-body experience (link). 

Feature #8:  an out-of-body experience experience that includes observations of things that should have been impossible for a person to observe, giving his actual body position.

A patient who had an out-of-body experience during a dental operation reported seeing two pennies on top of a high shelf while the patient floated above her body. The dentist got a ladder, and found that the two pennies were really there (link). 

Many people have heard of one or two of these veridical near-death experiences, perhaps the Pam Reynolds case or the often-told story about “Maria's shoe.” But judging from the book The Self Does Not Die: Verified Paranormal Phenomena from Near-Death Experiences, these veridical near-death experiences may not be so rare. Below are some of the cases documented in that book.

Case 2.1: A dying cancer patient remarked to Ricardo Ojeda-Vera (a doctor's assistant) that he had written a beautiful letter to his mother. Ojeda-Vera had written such a letter. The patient “described in detail exactly what he had written,” and accurately recounted that he had worn a green bathrobe while writing the letter. The patient claimed to have seen Ojeda-Vera writing the letter while she had “looked down on him from the ceiling.” Three days later the patient died.

Case 2.2: A patient reported having an out-of-body experience (OBE) during a cardiac arrest, and reported seeing a penny on the top of a cabinet. The cabinet was checked, and a penny was found there.

Case 2.3: In this well-known case, a woman named Maria reported floating out of her body during a cardiac arrest, and that during such an experience she saw a dark blue tennis shoe on a ledge near a window on the third floor. A search found such a shoe in such a location.

Case 2.5: At a hospital a woman who had a cardiac arrest reported having an out-of-body experience during which she floated out of her body, and saw a 12-digit serial number on the top of a six-foot tall respirator. The respirator was later checked and found to have exactly that number on its top.

Case 2.6: A man reported having an out-of-body experience during which he observed a 1985 quarter atop an 8-foot-high cardiac monitor. The top of the monitor was checked, and a 1985 quarter was found on its top.

Case 2.8: A man reported having an out-of-body experience during which he observed medical workers putting defibrillation paddles on him and gel. This matched his actual medical experience during his cardiac resuscitation.

Case 2.11: a woman reported floating out of her body during a cardiac arrest, and that during such an experience she rose up through the hospital's floors, rising up above the roof, where she saw the skyline and a red shoe. A search of the hospital's roof found a red shoe on the roof.

Case 2.12: A man reported that during his cardiac operation he floated out of his body and returned to his home, where he saw a caretaker having sex there with his girlfriend. The caretaker admitted this had happened.

Case 2.13: A woman reported that during her operation she floated out of her body and saw doctors telling her family (incorrectly) that she had died. It was later confirmed that the family had been told that.

Case 2.14: A woman reported having a near-death experience in which she looked down at her body from a corner of a hospital room during her operation. She then reported seeing in a paranormal way two of her grandmothers saying in a cafeteria that they were going to have a cigarette, even though neither smoked. It was confirmed that this improbable thing had happened.

Case 2.15: A patient in the intensive care unit of the hospital had a near-death experience in which he was reportedly able to hear the conversations of relatives elsewhere in the hospital, such as a waiting room conversation about a green toy tractor knocking down a wall of toy bricks. The conversations had occurred far away from his location in the hospital.

Case 3.1: A woman put under general anesthesia during her operation reported details of her operations from an “on the ceiling” perspective, and also correctly reported details of an operation in the adjacent operating room, such as the amputation of a leg and its placement in a yellow bag. She made the report as soon as she woke up, and had no way of knowing such information.

Case 3.7: A man missing his dentures correctly reported a nurse putting them in the drawer of a cart during his cardiac resuscitation, when he should have been completely unconscious.

Case 3.8 A man reported a near-death experience during cardiac arrest. He reported that during the medical efforts to revive him, he saw that a nurse dropped a tray and was scolded about it by a doctor. The account was confirmed.

Case 3.9 A woman had a near-death experience during cardiac arrest. She reported hovering in a corner of the room near the ceiling, and noticed a rose-shaped hair clip and a bottle breaking, details she should have been unaware of. The details were accurate.

Case 3.10 A patient unconscious during his operation reported floating above his body, and accurately described details of his operation.

Case 3.11 This dramatic near-death experience account is told in the youtube.com interview here. A patient was written off for dead, and had no vital signs for "close to 20 minutes." During that time he had "no heart beat, no blood pressure, no respiratory function."  But then in a seemingly miraculous manner the patient's vital signs reappeared, and he eventually "recovered fully." The patient described a near-death experience in which he observed post-it notes in the operating room that he should have been unable to observe because his eyes were taped and he was unconscious. The details were accurate.
 

Case 3.12 A patient whose heart was stopped reported a near-death experience in which he heard some paramedic say something to the effect that the patient would never revive, but a rookie paramedic could use the patient to practice CPR. After undergoing an amazing recovery, the patient told what he had heard to one of the paramedics, who was amazed that the man had apparently heard what the paramedic had said.

Case 3.16 Medical staff tried to save a patient who had undergone cardiac arrest, and they decided to stop the resuscitation efforts. They later found a faint pulse, and resumed the revival efforts. The man survived, and described the medical efforts trying to revive him. He “got all the details right, which was impossible” because he had no pulse during such efforts.

Case 3.18 A man who had a cardiac arrest during an operation reported to his doctor that he had seen a brown leather key fob fall out of the doctor's pocket during the operation. The doctor confirmed that such a thing had happened, at a time when the patient should have been unconscious.

Case 3.29: This case is the famous Pam Reynolds case, which I discuss here (while also discussing an equally astonishing case more recent).  While having her senses blocked and her temperature dramatically lowered during an operation that should have guaranteed unconsciousness, Reynolds reported a near-death that included very specific details of her operation she should have been unaware of. 

Case 3.30: A boy who underwent cardiac arrest recalled that during the medical efforts to revive him he "had been up in a corner of the room and had looked down on his body." He correctly recalled several details of the procedure. 

Case 3.33: A man who underwent cardiac arrest reported an out-of-body experience in which he felt himself "rising up through the ceiling" and then seeing some hospital area  in which there were mannequins. Above the ICU he was in was a CPR training area in which there were dummies (resembling mannequins) used for CPR training. 

Feature #9:  an experience of having an exalted intellect or speeded-up mind during an out-of-body experience

On page 81 of Green's book, she states, "Subjects usually report that their intellectual faculties were unimpaired in the 

ecsomatic [out-of-body] state; indeed, their reports often suggest a greater than usual degree of mental clarity, and some subjects assert explicitly that their intellectual functions often improved in the ecsomatic [out-of-body] state."  On page 69 of Green's book we read an account by someone who says his intelligence seemed sharper during his out-of-body experience. 

On page 71 of the 1918 book Man Is a Spirit by J. Arthur Hill (a very interesting collection of spontaneous paranormal experiences) we have an account by John Huntley of an out-of-body experience, an account in which he claims to have a greatly enhanced mind during his out-of-body experience:

"About five years ago I woke from sleep to find 'myself' clean out of the body, as the kernel of a nut comes out of its shell. I was conscious in two places — in a feeble degree, in the body which was lying in bed on its left side; and to a far greater degree, away from the body (far away, it seemed), surrounded by white opaque light, and in a state of absolute happiness and security (a curious expression, but one which best conveys the feeling). The whole of my personality lay 'out there,' even to the replica of the body — which, like the body, lay also on its left side. I was not conscious of leaving the body, but woke up out of it. It was not a dream, for the consciousness was an enhanced one, as superior to the ordinary waking state as that is to the dream state."

In 1983 Bruce Greyson MD created a 16-item Greyson Scale questionnaire  listing features often reported in near-death experiences. The scale is used to judge whether an experience should be classified as a near-death experience, with people reporting 7 or more of its items being classified as having had a near-death experience. Because reports of speeded-up thinking were fairly common in near-death experiences, one of the 16 items on the 16-item Greyson Scale questionnaire  is a question asking, "Were your thoughts speeded up?" In the 1983 paper that introduced the Greyson Scale, Greyson reported data on 74 people who reported something like a near-death experience. Of those, 53% reported an out-of-body experience, 46% reported "thoughts unusually vivid," 30% reported "sudden understanding," 23% reported extrasensory perception, and 19% reported "thinking unusually fast." 0% reported "thinking blurred or dull." Near-death experiences often include a "life review" experience, with 22% of the 74 in Greyson's paper reporting such a thing. During such a life review experience, thinking or mental experience is typically reported as occurring super-fast, with people describing the life review by saying things such as "my whole life flashed before me in an instant."

In a 2014 paper about near-death experiences, which often involve out-of-body experiences, the author states this about near-death experiences (NDE):

"The NDERF survey asked, 'How did your highest level of consciousness and alertness during the experience compare to your normal, everyday consciousness and alertness?' Of 1,122 NDErs surveyed, 835 (74.4%) indicated they had 'More consciousness and alertness than normal'; 229 (20.4%) experienced 'Normal consciousness and alertness'; and only 58 (5.2%) had 'Less consciousness and alertness than normal.'

In table 2 of the 2003 paper here, 44% of 27 people having near-death experiences reported "accelerated thought processes" and 70% reported a "sense of being out of the physical body." 

A very long post related to this long post is my post "Prevailing Brain Dogmas Cannot Explain Hypnotic Phenomena" which you can read here. In that post I describe 13 phenomena reported during hypnosis, none of which are explicable under prevailing dogmas about the brain. Item #10 in that list was "Exaltation of thinking and speaking abilities under hypnosis." I quote cases of people who seemed to think much  faster and much better under hypnosis than in normal consciousness. Although not involving out-of-body experiences, such cases tend to lend credence to reports that the mind can be sped up during an out-of-body experience. 

Feature #10:  an ability to mentally move around by merely willing it.

On page 86 of Green's book she says that some people having out-of-body experiences report the ability to change their viewing position by merely willing it. She quotes one person as saying, "I experimented by moving about my room with a kind of floating or

drifting movement, some feet above the ground, and learned that

direction was quite easily controlled by will."

On page 691 of the research paper here, we read of a person reporting many out-of-body experiences. We read that "he reported that every time his Self separated from his physical body, it was able to inspect

different remote places including settings which didn't seem to be of Earthly origin. Moreover, he was able to do so at the speed of thought and independently of distance involved between his physical body and the place his Self tried to reach."

On page 260 of George H. Hepworth's 1895 account of an out-of-body experience, which begins here, he seems to report moving great  distances by an act of will or desire:

"The most intense desire to see her seized me. It was a longing so poignant, so sharp, that it was painful. This ardor seemed to be an impelling force, and I new with incredible speed through the darkness. The camp, the lake, the mountains, were lost to view almost instantly, while other mountains and lakes came within range of my astonished vision."

Recalling an out-of-body experience, a Mr. Brown states this:

"I became conscious to find myself apparently floating over my 

Physical Body at a height of five to six feet...I willed myself

to move forward in the air, in a horizontal position, feet first until

I was quite clear of the house."

Feature #11:  an experience of seeming to re-enter the body after having been separated from it.

(1) On pages 57-58 of an Italian book (the text of which can be easily translated using Google Translate), we read that Mrs. Nathalie Annenkof reported an out-of-body experience, and said this about the end of an out-of-body experience:

"I approached my lying body and tried to enter it. I immediately felt that it absorbed me, like a sheet of blotting paper, or like a sponge absorbs water."

(2) A report of out-of-body experiences can be read in the 1936 book 'Twixt Earth and Heaven by Annie Britain, which you can read here. On page 53 she states this:

"I should mention in passing that I am seldom conscious of leaving the body. I simply find myself standing beside my sleeping form. The sensation on returning is always distinct; it is a sort of shock-the kind · of physical shock one experiences when one wakes from sleep with a  start. How I really enter I cannot explain; we seem to fuse into each other with a sort of snap."

(3) German government official Annamarie Renger reported leaving her body, and said that when she returned, it was like passing through a small tube (link). 

(4) The account below is from page 62 of the January 26, 1934 edition of the periodical Light, which you can read here. We read of someone re-entering his body after an out-of-body experience, saying, "I seemed to dissolve into a quick-silver-like fluid and slipped into my body by the toes":

On page 18 of the study here, we have some comments by four people reporting out-of-body experiences:

• "Getting back into my physical body was like a gentle lowering of my dissociated self into my body except for the back of my head which felt like it wouldn't go back in, but as I persisted it suddenly went back in with a sort of thud."
• "It felt like my dissociated self slammed back into my body."
• "I returned to my body as though I was abruptly falling from a certain height."
• "The return ....felt like a suction, or that I was shot back into my physical body in one quick motion."

Table 7 of the same paper (on page 16) tells us that 50+ people reported that at the end of their out-of-body experience they "felt a sensation of movement toward and/or reintegrating with the physical body."

Hallucinations produce random output, and when you get reports that follow an extremely characteristic pattern, then hallucination is not a credible explanation. Did all four people in your house report seeing at different times a man with a red hat and a green cape walking by your house? Then you could not have all been hallucinating this. 

The similarities in out-of-body experiences are far too great to be explained by any hypothesis of hallucination. We have too much of a repetition of extremely distinctive features to be explained under any theory of hallucination. The probability of random hallucinations producing so many out-of-body experience accounts so similar seems as small as the probability that many people all over the world in many different countries would all report (purely because of coincidentally similar random hallucinations) that they all saw a pink elephant smoking a cigar.

There is no substance in any neuroscientist attempt to explain out-of-body experiences or near-death experiences.  The attempts that have been made by neuroscientists to explain such phenomena have been largely characterized by dishonesty, misstatements and irrelevance. For a critical discussion of some of the attempts that have been made, see my post "There Is No Evidence of a Neural Explanation for Out-of-Body Experiences" which you can read here, and my post "Misleading Claims in Attempts to Naturally Explain Near-Death Experiences and Out-of-Body Experiences," which you can read here, and also my post "The Guardian's Misleading Story on Near-Death Experiences" which you can read here. 

After making a very thorough study of reports of out-of-body experiences, an objective scholar will be led to the conclusion that they are among the most decisive items of evidence against the claim that the mind is a product of the brain. Along with brain physical shortfalls that show your brain cannot be the cause of the main ordinary aspects of human mentality, out-of-body experiences prove that you are a soul, not a brain.